Friday, November 15, 2013

Open Prompt 11/17/13

2006 Open Prompt: A country setting is often used by many readers to establish values within a piece of literature. The country may be a place of virtue, peace, primitivism, and ignorance. Choose a novel or a play in which the country plays a significant role, and then write an essay analyzing how the country functions in the work as a whole.


Essay 3A:
The student choose to write an essay on Jane Austen’s Persuasion. The essay achieves its objective of explaining the significance of  the countryside to the novel. The introduction has a three pronged thesis that shows you exactly what the student will be addressing in the essay: “Although many writers may convey the countryside as a setting of ignorance and primitivism, Austen endows her countryside with nurturing, virtuous, and peaceful quality”. It would be better for purpose of organization if he/she mentioned the three different things they will be addressing in the order they’re planning to go about it. There are specific examples to support that are used by the student and that strengthens the essay. The final paragraph ties everything together and explains how the countryside is important for the protagonist’s development. This is specifically answers the prompt again. The essay was well written and organized overall. There were a few grammatical errors and abbreviations used in the essay. The organization not coinciding with the thesis was the only other noticeable flaw of the essay. Overall the essay accomplishes its objective well and that is why it received an 8. I agree with the score because it was well written, but it had some mistakes that would prevent it from receiving a 9.

Essay 3B:
The student chose to write an essay: The Importance of Being Earnest The first paragraph explains how the setting in the book contributed to the book. The paragraph also mentions the character, but it is unclear how the country setting relates to him. That hurts the essay because that is crucial to answering the prompt and should be clear from the get go. This is clearer in the next paragraph, where Jack “flees to the countryside”. Then the student goes off topic on comedic confusion and all it does is distract from the actual essay. In the final paragraph the student attempts to tie it all together, but is not able to because the essay goes off topic and did not directly address the prompt. Overall though the student did answer the prompt though it was very weak, with very little analysis provided to back up the claims made in the essay. The idea was good, but it definitely needs much more work as a result the student received a 6. I agree with the score because the student had a good idea, but didn’t execute it well.


Essay 3C:
The student choose to write his/her essay As I lay Dying. The introduction is short and the thesis states that the setting “dictates” the plot. The thesis and introduction would be stronger if the student just referred to the setting as the countryside, as was stated in the prompt. The student gives example throughout the essay, but never really ties it all together. The essay was more of a character explanation; this would have been fine if there was analysis on how the countryside affected them. The part of the countryside is practically left out of the response, and that is a big problem considering the fact that was pretty much the whole prompt. The student’s response barely addresses the prompt even indirectly, but there is a serious lack of thorough analysis, so it is not surprising that the student received a 3. I agree with the score and I think it would improve a lot if there was more in depth analysis and if the prompt was answered directly at least once.


3 comments:

  1. Susheela,
    I'll start off by mentioning that I really like how you provided the prompt of the essay in the beginning for us. No other student in AP Lit has done that, and it makes it a lot easier to put your criticisms in context. In your first criticism, I enjoyed your suggestion that addressing the issues that will be discussed later in the student's essay is better organizationally. However, in all three of your criticisms, you seem to just summarize the student's writing rather than summarize and then explain what was right and wrong about it. I think it is important to address this because as a critic, it is essential to discuss why the writing was good or bad. Overall, well done, but remember to delve deeper into the inner layers of writing and discuss things such as DIDLS.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Impressive critiques, Susheela! Very thorough. I happened to do this same prompt a while back, interestingly enough. You did a nice job summarizing the student's essays and stating their successes and failures, but I feel that you're lacking in terms of actual textual evidence that justifies the scores you gave them. For example, when commending the first student's essay on Austen's Persuasion, you mentioned her ample use of textual evidence, but you failed to provide any examples of it that may have made the reasons for your scoring more clear to myself and other readers of your critiques. My only recommendation for next time would be to avoid over summarization and look carefully at why the student deserves the score you give to them. Not that you didn't do that, but I think that making it more clear to your readers would improve the quality of your critiques. All in all, good work!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Susheela,
    You do an amazing job. I thought that you did a great job on summarizing the student's writing and later tell why they got their scores. Although you do a great job of summarizing, I feel that you could add quotes from the essays to support your claims and explain why the students got their scores. Maybe look at what the AP Scorers said about it? Did you agree or disagree with them? What did were your thoughts as you were reading them?

    ReplyDelete