Sunday, April 27, 2014

We’ve been really busy in class these last few weeks preparing for the AP exam and it’s coming soonL .We finished up Ceremony discussions, completed a forum, started/finished the Weebly project, and started Fifth Business.  
            I wish we had more time to discuss Ceremony (really everything we’ve read) because I feel like I’m still missing things in the novel. The discussions helped a lot to clear up my confusion about the story lines. The plot summary was hard though for me to write for our summary and analysis blog post. I don’t think I’ll use Ceremony in an essay because of that.
            We had to write about the symbols in the story Women Hollering Creek by Sandra Cisneros. I wrote about the symbolism of the names of the characters. It was interesting to see through the responses we also posted how the different symbols all connected together. I formatted my post similar to that of an introduction to an open/closed prompt, but with evidence. That was good practice and I’m sure I’ll need it.
            Then we wrote a paper on one of the works we’ve read in class. We had a lot more freedom with the assignment than I had in other classes. We were supposed to write a paper similar to the one’s we’ve read in class. For Lindsay and I the introduction was actually the hardest part and then finding other papers that supported what we were arguing. I was really surprised at how difficult it was to find evidence to support how Elsinore affects Hamlet. I took a while to find article that were about it much more than it did with other research papers I had to write in Lit Comp 10/Brit Lit. After all of that the writing wasn’t very hard.

              

Sunday, April 20, 2014

Open Prompt 2 (4/20/14)

2005, Form B. One of the strongest human drives seems to be a desire for power. Write an  essay in which you discuss how a character in a novel or a drama struggles to free himself or herself from the power of others or seeks to gain power over others. Be sure to demonstrate in your essay how the author uses this power struggle to enhance the meaning of the work.

            In William Shakespeare’s Hamlet Claudius kills his own brother to become king by doing this he obtains power over almost everyone and tries to maintain it. He fears that Hamlet will take that power away from him though and Claudius is willing to kill Hamlet to stay in power. Shakespeare uses this power struggle to show how that when one disrupts the natural order by usurping power it will lead to the downfall of all involved.

            Claudius kills Old Hamlet and he also marries his brother’s wife Gertrude. Being king gives Claudius over everyone including Gertrude, but being her husband gives him even more. While he may have killed Old Hamlet because he loved Gertrude he gains much more power than he had before. He also takes that power away from Hamlet who was supposed to succeed his father. Being married to his mother gives Claudius a unique sense of power over Hamlet. Claudius does not want Hamlet to leave Denmark he wants him to stay to keep an eye on what he is doing. Gertrude asks Hamlet to stay for her and that is what Claudius wants. He also asserts his power over Hamlet by practically mocking his emotions concerning his father’s death. This is the start of a power struggle between the two.

            While Claudius has gained power over others, he has not gained full control over Hamlet. Hamlet wants to kill him and avenge his father. Claudius discovers this by overhearing Hamlet and Ophelia. Hamlet is the only real threat left to his power, so Claudius decides to send Hamlet of to England where he is to be killed. This by default will give him power over Hamlet by dictating his fate.

            Instead of dying in England, Hamlet returns to Denmark where he kills Claudius. Shakespeare uses this power struggle to show that usurping power will lead to the downfall of all the parties involved in it. Claudius first usurped power by killing his brother the king that sets all of this in motion. If he had not killed Old Hamlet his son would not have set out to avenge him. Claudius’s attempt to gain power demonstrates the consequences of usurpation.

            

Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Ceremony Summary and Analysis


  • Author:
    • The author is Leslie Marmon Silko and she wrote it while living in Ketchikan, Alaska. She is Laguna Pueblo, Mexican, and white. So similar to Tayo she is mixed ethnically.
  • Setting:
    • There are multiple settings; they change according to where Tayo is mentally and physically. Also the poems that are also in the novel have different settings. Tayo minds goes back and forth from the hospital in California, the reservation in New Mexico (where he is from), and the Philippines (where he fought during WWII). The stories Betonie tells also have different settings.
  • Characters:
    • Tayo: He is a veteran returning from WWII and is the protagonist of the novel. Doctors diagnose him with PTSD, but there is much more going on than that.  Tayo grew up on the Laguna reservation; his mother was Laguna and his father was white. As a result he is shunned by some in the community and others are envious of him. His mother left him with Josiah, Auntie, and Grandma when he was four years old.
    • Betonie: Is a healer, but he believes in changing ceremonies. He is also of mixed descent similar to Tayo. He is able to help Tayo.
    • Ts'eh: she also helps Tayo heal and is many figures in Laguna cosmology. She helps make the land more fertile, drought is a problem throughout the novel. She is in a relationship with Tayo.
    • Josiah: is Tayo’s uncle from his mother’s side. He practically adores Josiah because he does not really treat him any different than Rocky. Josiah has a relationship with Night Sawn and buys cattle. Tayo sees Josiah’s death while he is in the Philippines when Josiah is still in Laguna.
    • Night Swan: she is in a relationship with Josiah and she is Mexican. Later on she seduces Tayo.
    • Rocky: is Tayo’s cousin who is treated better by Auntie because he is full Laguna. However Rocky does not relate to their culture and has dreams involving college and other things. He is killed in the Philippines and his death haunts Tayo.
    • Auntie: is Tayo’s mother’s sister who criticizes Laura for having a child with a white man. While she also tries to follow western culture and wants Rocky to follow it too. She treats Tayo very differently than Rocky because of their pedigree.
    • Grandma: is Rocky and Tayo’s grandmother who tells the story about the test of the atomic bomb that they saw. She also makes a comment that she has heard this story before just with different names.
    • Robert: is Tayo’s uncle who is married to Auntie. Robert does not seem to treat Tayo the way Auntie does and at certain moments seems genuinely concerned for him.
    • Laura: is Tayo’s mother who died when he was a child. She wanted to become more
    • Helen Jean: is a women Harley and Leroy meet at a bar and she is from a different tribe.
    • Emo: he grew up with Tayo, but never liked him. He also fought in WWII and he now drinks similar to many other veterans struggling to return to their old life. Emo is also envious of Tayo because he is half white. He also glorifies the war and has not left it behind. Near the end of the book is kills Harley, Leroy, and Pinkie. He was originally hoping to kill Tayo who he had previously gotten into a fight with.
    • Leroy: another one of Tayo’s friends that now is dependent on alcohol.
    • Pinkie: Emo’s friend and was also friends with Tayo at one point.
    • Harley: a veteran and one of Tayo’s good friends, but he is an alcoholic.
    • Descheeny: is Betonie’s grandfather.
    • Mexican Girl: is Betonie’s grandmother.
  • Plot:
    • The story of Tayo is being told by Thought Women and Betonie.
    • Tayo has come back from the war, but is ill and as a result spends time in the veteran’s hospital. He eventually becomes healthy enough to return home to his home the Laguna reservation.
    • During the war, Tayo thinks that he sees Josiah dye, but actually he died in Laguna.
    • There is a drought back at the Laguna Reservation and Tayo regrets wishing that it would stop raing during the war. He also remembers carrying Rocky when he was injured.
    • Tayo spends time with his old friends and drinks with them. Once when he was in a bar he stabbed Emo in the belly. He did this because he was glorifying the war and the belly is where the stories he tells about the war are supposed to be kept.
    • The medicine man performs a ceremony on him, but it does not do much good. Tayo starts to think about when he and Rocky were children. He also remembers how Auntie treated him and how she tried to separate him from Rocky.
    • Josiah also meets Night Swan, a Mexican woman who he falls in love with. When Tayo goes to give her a note from Josiah she seduces him.
    • Tayo goes to Betonie, another medicine man, who is supposed to cure him. Betonie believes that ceremonies should change and that people should not cling to them. Tayo starts to search for Joaisah’s cattle again.
    • A mountain lion helps him find the cattle. He met a women earlier, Ts'eh, who also with the hunter. He meets him and sees that she has found the cattle.
    • Tayo continues to take care of the cattle as he spends more time with Ts'eh. Robert tells him that there are rumors at the reservation that he is sick again.
    • Ts'eh then tells him that people are coming to take him away because they believe he is sick again. This is because of Emo spreading rumors and lies. Tayo tries to escape them, but he runs into Harley and Leroy who he believes are his friends. While really they are working with Emo.
    • Tayo leaves them and tires to hide. During this he witness Harley being tortured and killed. Tayo wanted to intervene, but he realized that it would complete the witches’ ceremony.
    • Tayo completes his ceremony and returns home. Later Emo kills Pinkie and he is sent away to California. Grandma mentions that this whole story is familiar to her and the only difference is that the characters have different names.
    • The novel ends with another poem.
  • Tone:
    • The tone of the play is gloomy, but later there is hope. It is gloomy when Tayo is in a state of confusion and is physically/emotionally ill. The Laguna believe that everything is connected and that there must be balance for harmony; Tayo’s illness affects them all in different ways. In these moments the tone of the novel is gloomy. The tone becomes hopeful later in the play. Hope can be seen in the novel when the land becomes fertile again and Tayo meets The Women.
  • Point of View:
    • It is mostly third person and the story of Tayo is being told in the novel.
  • Style:
    • Silko’s style is very unique in that “Ceremony” is a novel with poems intertwined in them. The story of Tayo is being told in the novel and the poems also tell different stories too.  
  • Theme:
    • In “Ceremony”, Leslie Marmon Silko suggests that good and evil exist in everything and are therefore arbitrary classifications; understanding this allows one to achieve a personal and communal balance.
Silko uses race to depict good and evil, but clarifies that it does not mean any race is purely good or evil. Both exist in anything and anyone. She uses the white race to symbolize evil, but not to mean it in the literal sense. Silko uses the witchery to represent and show all evil. Silko says the witchery is really to blame and that people are “fooled into blaming only the whites and not the witchery” (231). “Human beings were one clan” and not separate races(228). For there to be harmony there must be a balance between good and evil. This is achieved when Emo is sent away to California; he is a witch. The evil is “dead for now”, but both always exist and can never cease to exist (243).
  • Imagery:
    • There is a lot of imagery throughout the novel from the description of the cattle to the description of the clothing, “the hem of her floral print dress swaying” (16).
  • Symbolism:
    • Gallup Ceremonial: it shows how Native Americans are misunderstood and their culture is not appreciated. It is organized by the mayor of Gallup and others. The ceremonial is not held for a special reason as it would be Native Americans.