Sunday, December 22, 2013

Response to Course Material: 12/22/13

We have spent all of our time focusing on Hamlet since the last response to course material post post. We read the play in class together, then watched parts of multiple versions of the movie, and read poems/articles on it. I missed the first day we started to read the play in class and that definitely made it all bit confusing. After we first read the play I had my own version of what the play was in my mind; watching different versions of Hamlet did change it.
It was interesting watching each version, they highlighted different things in the play. I really liked the setting for the Branaugh and Tennet versions. I thought that they both showed how there was always spying in Elsinore and the idea that there is something wrong there. Then I liked the casting in the Jacobi version compared to the other ones, especially for Laertes. I liked the casting in the Hawke version too, but Hawke’s Hamlet seemed to be monotone. He lacked the complexity that I personally think is  vital to Hamlet. His Hamlet just seemed really depressed and no other emotion was really apparent in the movie. I thought the movie had an interesting take on Laertes and Ophelia relationship that the others didn’t. The play in general reminds me of Death of a Salesman because of how you discover something new every time you read it or watch it again.  
I really enjoyed reading the articles on Hamlet, especially the one about the Tiv and their interpretation on the play Hamlet. It showed how subjective interpretations are and as a result the “true” meaning is too. The forum posts created a debate over whether there was a “correct” interpretation. I don’t think there is because everything is subjective and that includes whatever we personally think is the right version. This applies to other things too, from movies to music. Then the other two pieces on the forums were Rimbaud’s poem and the story about prisoners acting out Shakespeare. Rimbaud’s poem brought to mind who is really to blame for Ophelia’s death? Is there ever really anyone to to blame with suicide anyway? What about another Shakespeare play then, can anyone be blamed for Romeo and Juliet's death? The prisoners also showed Hamlet in a new light because they could connect with him in a way that we can’t.
We also had in class discussions over the play and the different versions of Hamlet that we watched. Someone made the analogy that if Hamlet was in a band he would be the lead singer, Horatio would be  the base player, Polonius would be the stage manager, the Queen and Ophelia would be groupies, and so on. I thought that this was funny, but it also did help with understanding the characters. As discussions continued we started to go more in depth, especially after our close reading. Another thing that came up was the Biblical references and parallels in play. Hamlet is typically considered the good guy, but it is hard to deny that there are parallels with him and Satan. Satan also tried to usurp God and that is what lead to him to being punished. He also started off as the good guy and it is apparent in the beginning of the play that he is good, but that changes as the play goes on. This comparison reminded me of Paradise Lost by Milton because of comparison with Satan and I learned the more about Satan after reading it last year in British Literature.
We also annotated Tragic Balance in Hamlet. I’m ended up being absent the day we discussed it in class, but I heard that it was a good discussion and I know that some of the classes really didn’t like it. My main issue was that the article was confusing because of all the ideas and it was difficult to tell which quotes were supporting the author or an older idea. It was still an interesting article though.

Thursday, December 12, 2013

Open Prompt: 2008 Question 3 12/15/13

2008 “The prompt for question 3, the “open” question, began by noting that in literary works, a minor character, often known as a foil, possesses traits that emphasize, by contrast or comparison, the distinctive characteristics and qualities of the main character. The prompt added that the ideas or behavior of the minor character might be used to highlight the weaknesses or strengths of the main character. Students were then asked to choose a novel or play in which a minor character serves as a foil to a main character and to write an essay analyzing how the relation between the minor character and the major character illuminates the meaning of the work as a whole”.
Essay 3A:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Joy Luck Club. One of the flaws of the essay is that the second and third paragraphs are mostly filled with plot summary. There is very little, if any, analysis in the paragraphs. This is clear when you first start to read the essay. The student received an 8, if they had more analysis with the summary and/or less summarization in the essay as a whole they probably could have gotten a 9.  The paragraph has a very good ending; it had a quote from the book and it helped wrap up the paragraph. The student had an adequate conclusion; it started with restating the thesis. Then ended with a strong and clear sentence: “Hung Taitai helped to highlight and emphasize all of Lindos good qualities”.  This sentence specifically answered the prompt, though it was less clear throughout the essay. It is a bit surprising that the essay received an 8 because it seemed to summarize too much, not focus on answering the prompt, and it didn’t have enough analysis. The essay did have a lot of evidence and a good introduction.
Essay 3B:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Color Purple. This was a fairly good essay overall. One problem that was noticeable early on was that the prompt was not answered early in the essay. Ideally the prompt would be answered in the first paragraph. It is only clear in the conclusion that the Celle’s father “serv(es) as her foil, he represents every characteristic that Celle learns not to be”. This is the only time that the prompt was directly answered and that was in the conclusion, which is late. The other issue with the essay is that there is more evidence for Shug to be Celle’s foil instead of her father in the essay. The student says that Celle was not independent and Shug is the opposite of that. This is discussed in the essay and it is unclear who the foil is till the end of the essay is. It received a 6 and I can understand why. The essay was fairly well written, but it was a bit confusing.
Essay 3C:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Kite Runner.  The student should try to vary his/her sentence structure more in the future. Majority of the sentences in the essay are fairly simple, “he emphasizes the good qualities in Hassan”. This would be fine if the short simple sentences were only used once in a while, especially to create emphasis. The problem is that they are common in the essay and as a result there is now flow. Also while some of the previous essays summarized too much, this one did not give a summary or background information on the plot much at all. This makes it difficult for someone who has not read the book to understand the essay. The student should also try to use more evidence and explain it. He/she did answer the prompt but not very well. The essay got a 4 and I agree with the score. The essay was underdeveloped, but it answered the prompt and has room for potential.


Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading: Inside the Box (12/8/13)

In the article Inside the Box Jessica Olien draws attention to how society adamantly claims that it loves creativity, but constantly shuns it. She explains how it is commonly unaccepted providing examples as evidence for her assertions. Then goes on to emphasize how it is under attack by society in numerous ways. Olien uses diction, syntax, and details to show how creativity is constantly praised, but in reality it is under attack by society.

Olien uses diction well to further her argument. In the first paragraph she refers to creativity as a “virtue” and a trait that is “celebrated”. This helps set a positive tone for the first paragraph because the word “virtue” and “celebrated” have good and happy connotations. These two words also give the reader the idea that creativity is very important. Later in the seventh paragraph Olien gives references the documentary The September Issue (about Vogue magazine), and she points out that the many ideas of the creative director are “reject(ed)” by Anna Wintour (editor-in-cheief). Olien does not simply say that the ideas are simply “reject(ed)”, but “systematically reject(ed)”. This is an important difference because of what the word “systematically” implies to the reader: that creativity is constantly denied and that this single example is universal. Olien’s word choice helps her convey her message to the reader.

While the tone of the first paragraph was positive, it came to a screeching halt in the second paragraph with one simple little sentence, “It’s all a lie”. The sentence is emphasized because of how short it is, especially compared to the rest of Olien’s sentences. It draws emphasis to the main idea of her article: that society claims to love creativity, but truly hate it. The sentence comes after what was discussed about diction in the first paragraph, so it also contrasts with that, and the short sentence emphasizes it because of how abrupt it is. She also uses hyphens to draw emphasis to other parts of the article. In the eleventh paragraph Olien highlights a “place where our first creative ideas go to die is the place that should be most open to them-schools”. The hyphen adds emphasis to the idea that schools hurt creativity, even though it is a long sentence. Olien utilizes syntax well to change the tone and add emphasis. All of this is to show how creativity is not widely valued and accepted, even though people think it is.

The details included in the article help Olien make her case. She includes a quote from Dave Hickey: “Everybody hates it when something’s really great”. This detail is significant because it reinforces the idea that creativity is great and that it is not accepted at once. The quote (in context) also implies that the reason behind creativity being rejected is people do not like success of others. This is a very negative concept and is used by Olien to strengthen her argument that creativity is rejected for terrible reasons. Then she shows the value of creativity by including the detail how “adults’ accomplishments are linked far more strongly to their creativity than their IQ” in the twelfth paragraph. The detail comes in the paragraph that continues to discus schools and as a result the detail implies that creativity should be fostered at school and should be more important than education. The details included in the article are used by Olien to stress the importance of creativity and draw attention to why it is often rejected.


Diction, syntax, and details are used well by Olien to show creativity is not accepted even though it is important and should be. She uses them to explain to the reader while people claim to value creativity it, it is not valued. Then goes on to say that for creativity to succeed one must be determined and not give up on it.