Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response To Course Material 9/29

In these first couple of weeks in class we have covered multiple topics from Edward Albee’s The American Dream to AP writing prompts. All of the things we have covered so far tie together.


We started of learning how to annotate, with DIDILS (diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax). I realized that in previous classes that I had noticed and discussed components of this, even if I hadn't formally really annotated. This also gave me insight on my own writing.

We started off by focusing on diction and syntax, we looked at the diction of two excerpts. Then moved on to syntax, we received the handout Syntax as Style. We started of by taking small steps, first we saw examples (in the handout) on how syntax was used and had to apply it with a partner to one of the excerpts in the handout. This exercise really helped me, I struggled at first with it because my partner and I had picked Henry David Thoreau’s Walden and I wasn't used to the writing. Thoreau uses long sentences that flow well to create calm tone. I think struggling with this helped me in the end.


Imagery, another part of DIDLS, was a part I was very familiar with. We had discussed it in many of my previous classes. It is used very commonly to help convey meaning because it  appeals to the five senses. Imagery can be as simple as “It was a warm summer day”, the reader must be able to “see”, “feel”, “taste”, and “smell” what the author is describing.


When I first heard that details was part of DIDLS, I didn't really understand it. I thought everything was details, so what do you mean focus on the details? Now I understand how small details can make a difference. I also struggled with differentiating diction and language. I was sure how diction was really different from language. I learned that diction is more of a focus on isolated words, while language focuses on the whole.


We used the different components of DIDLS for the closed reading. I used an article from Slate, my first reaction to it was that I thought it was fairly well written and a good article. While focusing on the diction, details, and syntax, I started to disagree with the author and didn't like the tone the diction created. I was surprised that by the end of my close reading I had the opposite response to my initial one.


The close reading helped with learning how to annotate and it also helped with the AP writing we did in class. The open reading did the same except it was much more direct.I realized that some of the common mistakes that students make when writing responses to the prompts are similar to ones I have made before. Instead of actually responding to the question, you end up summarizing. I still thought that the writing we did in class was hard though but it gave me a good heads up on what to expect on the actual exam and in class. I think that there are significant differences between prompts that you can pick the literature for and other that have already assigned it.

All the parts of DIDLS, came together again when we read The American Dream. It is still debated the true meaning of the play. It was a fast read, and it allowed us to cover multiple topics in it. We received the handout Existentialism 101, once I understood what existentialism was I thought about what we had been learning in AP Government different philosophers from Locke to Plato. We also discussed Thomas Hobbes’s theories on government and people. I thought some of it was similar to existentialists. Existentialists believe that “there are no ‘universal’ guidelines”, Hobbes had a similar view. He thought that there weren't any rules or morals in a state of nature that regulated people’s actions. We also received a handout  on Theater of the Absurd, I thought this was really interesting to learn about. It was not something that I had much prior knowledge about. The American Dream is considered theater of the absurd. The way of thinking is cynical but it is hard to deny some of the truth, no matter how much it would please many to do so; it had a realistic approach. It was also really helpful to read different perspectives on The American Dream. Then we looked at the theories of comedy and the different types of them. I think comedies are very interesting and complicated when you look into specifics of them.  I knew there we different types of comedies but I never knew there were so many of them. There are many parodies out there, almost everybody has read and/or seen Twilight, but there are also parodies of it: Nightlight and Vampires Sucks. You can see how different forms of comedy is used and its purpose. 

The American Dream

  • We spent most of our time on The American Dream. The handouts that we received helped but just asking question and discussing is what I thought was the most useful personally. I personally like assignments that tell me exactly what to do and have one answer. I found the The American Dream a bit frustrating in that sense. Discussing the meaning was very interesting and I learned a lot form it. I thought that it also incorporated our summer work, Foster's book, on the meaning behind everything with it. For example sex isn't really just that, there is more meaning behind. This might be difficult for some to understand but in the play what is really shows is the lack of intimacy. Yes there is physical intimacy but there isn't any emotional intimacy or any real relationships.
  • When I first read this play I thought it was quite amusing. My thoughts on it completely changed after discussing it. When I read the scene with Grandma telling Mrs. Barker the story of the Bumble, I was shocked at first for sure. However I didn't fully grasp how dark it was. That scene had just confused me at first. 
  • Another interesting aspect was trying to classify The American Dream as a type of comedy after we received that handout. It was funny, at least at first, so almost everybody agreed that it was a comedy. The only disagreement was on why type. Some thought that it was high comedy, because the play appealed to people's intellect. I disagreed with this and so did some of my peers. High comedy appeals to the intellect but it is only funny if you can understand this appeal. Considering I had to disagree that The American Dream was high comedy. Once you look beyond the surface of the The American Dream, in other words try to understand the deeper meanings, ideas, and motifs; all the humor is thrown out of the window. It isn't funny, it's actually very dark. Considering that I thought of it as more of a low comedy because even if you didn't understand the underlying ideas you would still think it was funny after reading it.
  • I understood the ideas of consumerism and materialism in the play and that they were becoming a part of the The American Dream. I completely missed other things though in the book, for example the implication that Daddy had a sex change. I understood the role reversals in the play from the beginning but I hadn't realized the true extent till discussing it in class. This shows how matriculated he is and is supposed to add to the meaning of exchanged between Mommy and Daddy.

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt 9/22/13

In the 2005 AP exam the open prompt asked students to compare and contrast two poems by William Blake both titled “The Chimney Sweeper”. They needed to be able to discuss the different techniques used in each poem and their meaning.


Student Response #1:
The essay achieves its objectives of discussing the different uses of language and meaning even though it lacks a conclusion. The first paragraph introduces the main idea of the essay and explains the similarities and differences of the two works. It addresses the structural similarities of the two poems and difference in their tone. The second paragraph focuses on the similarities in style, rhyme scheme, and points out that Blake shows, “he has working class sensibilities” in both poems. The third paragraph centers on the differences of the two poems, from the tone to the explicitness of Blake’s message. The essay uses examples clearly to support main ideas. There is also a clear logical organization of ideas that allows a reader to understand the arguments made easily. The ideas are tied together well and work together to answer the prompt. The essay doesn’t have a conclusion that would help wrap up the essay and a clear thesis even though it meets the objectives of the open prompt. Also with and ‘and’ are not fully written out in the essay, instead the student uses w/ and &. Overall the essay is able to achieve its main goal.


Student Response #2:
The essay doesn’t fully achieve the main objectives. There are strong parts in the essay, were arguments are made well and elaborated on with examples. However in other places the student does not thoroughly discuss and defend the assertions made. The introduction discusses the use of poetry as a whole, as a means of change and introduces the different poetic techniques used in both poems. The introduction is choppy in making this jump.  The second paragraph focuses on the diction used and successfully discusses Blake’s use of dark/light and black/white as a metaphor to express the “innocence” of the children and their “death”. The third paragraph poorly discuses syntax and the rhyme scheme. The discussion of syntax is under covered and the claim is not supported well. The main focus of the third paragraph is how, “God is shown to have a different relationship to the young chimney sweeps”. This paragraph is a well-constructed, it has examples that are clearly explained. The fourth paragraph is the conclusion, the student tries to tie all the ideas presented in the essay together. However it yet again makes too big of a leap trying to expand into the effect these poems had on society in the past and how people today need to see the important “activism” in poetry. This conclusion does not strengthen the essay. Overall the essay focuses on the main objectives but there are parts that need clear improvement.   

Student Response #3:
This essay does not achieve the main objectives, it focuses on one thing: the role of God in each poem. The introduction discusses the difference in tone but the scoring commentary points out that this is an example of the student not understanding the use of irony. The second and third paragraph could be one paragraph because they both focus on the role of God in both poems. The second discusses how in one poem it leads to inspiring the boy.  While in the third paragraph it mentions how the role of God, “highlight[s] the hypocrisy of the boy’s parent’s actions”.  This is the only idea discussed thoroughly and it would help the student to of made it one whole paragraph. Breaking it into two doesn’t help and they seem redundant. The fourth paragraph (that is the conclusion) tries to tie all the ideas together but only the role of God was really discussed. Overall the essay does not answer the question, because it does not discuss any techniques.

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Close Reading: A Win-Win-Win for Everyone (Except the Syrians) by Fred Kaplan


In A Win-Win-Win for Everyone (Except the Syrians), Fred Kaplan discusses the resolution reached over the use of chemical weapons in the civil war in Syria. It is a comprehensive article that discusses the positions of Barack Obama, the United States’s Congress, Vladimir Putin, Bashar al-Assad, and the Syrians. The diction, syntax, and details used by Kaplan helps convey his biases views that everyone except the Syrians in a sense won whether it is Putin who won because of clever plotting and Obama who won because of sheer luck.

Kaplan uses formal diction throughout the article, there are numerous examples of this. The first example is in the fifth paragraph where he uses the word “gambit” describing Putin’s proposal that was criticized by some Americans. He could've used the word proposal, or tactic. However this word adds to creating an image of Putin as being clever and scheming; the one that set things into motion. This also aids him in portraying Obama as weak and cornered.  In the eighth paragraph Kaplan says “[Putin] took the narrowest slice of Obama’s rhetoric”, narrowest slice adds to the meaning. It gives the reader the impression that Putin found a loophole to get out of this whole mess. If Kaplan used a different phrase such as ‘part’ the reader would not be given that impression. Kaplan uses diction cleverly to portray Putin and Obama a certain way to convey his message. In the tenth paragraph, Kaplan says that Obama will get “at least joint credit” for the agreement. Kaplan did not need to use “at least”, he would have been fine leaving that out and just saying “joint credit”. However this would of given the reader a different impression. “[A]t least” makes it seem  that Obama got lucky with in the end and that he really did not have any real part in the result. Kaplan’s diction in this article paints Putin as the one who made the crucial decisions and now Obama is lucky with the results.

Kaplan also uses syntax to his advantage to deliver his message clearly. He uses sentence fragments to add emphasis and add the slight sense of confusion. In the eighth paragraph the last sentence is “End of story”. It adds emphasis and abruptly ends the trail of thought. This leaves the reader with the idea that Putin’s one move is what changed everything even though John Kerry and Sergey Lavrov were both discussing Syria. It is possible that Putin made the call but there is no way of knowing that for sure but the use of the sentence fragment leaves the reader with that impression. He uses a sentence fragment again to start the last paragraph, “And who knows?”. This emphasizes the ideas that are about to come and gives a sense of momentary confusion and unknown possibilities. That is what Kaplan says is possible because of this resolution. If that did not start the sentence the same idea would be portrayed but not as efficiently. The confusion brought on helps create the sense of unknown that Kaplan is trying to achieve.

The details that were in the article are important to notice. They help Kaplan send his message. He gives background information in the second and third paragraph on why Putin had very good motivation to have the chemical weapons removed. The information is crucial in creating the idea that Putin had more incentive to begin with than Obama to remove the chemical weapons. That Putin did not want or like the “chaos” that was created by Assad’s use of chemical weapons. This idea does have some merit however the image it paints does not. It make is seem that Putin has more motivation and that is where the idea of him having more power and control of the situation also begin. Then in the twelfth paragraph Kaplan mentions the “Chapter VII resolution—that is, a resolution that includes enforcement through the use of force.”. This detail adds to what the reader views Putin has been able to achieve. It makes it so that there are consequences for the Syrians not complying. It helps portray Putin as more powerful and of having been the one to bring about the resolution.
Kaplan uses diction, syntax, and details to give the reader the impression that the resolution was courtesy of Putin and Obama is lucky that it took place. It is biased in that sense, the article is not objective, it portrays Obama achieving his goal as just luck and not a result of his threats to strike Syria. This is seen through the analysis of the article.