Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material 10/27/2013

Over the last couple of weeks we finished The American Dream, went over multiple choice question, discussed poetry, started Death of  a Salesman. This is a lot of information that we have covered.

I really love that we read the plays and have so much time to discuss in class. It really helps you dig into a novel or play. We finished our discussions of The American Dream, and we had to write a theme statement for it. I struggled to include all the different parts of the play in that statement. One thing that I learned was that I don’t need to include every little details in the theme statement. I also realized that before sometime I would pull out a motif as the theme.
When we discussed the theme as a class there was some disagreement over it. We finally settled on a theme, but I changed a few aspects of it. I really like this, the fact that we weren’t limited to one theme as a class, but we also were allowed to use the same one if we all agreed upon it. The idea of having to write a full theme statement on my own is a bit daunting, but it really helped to hear all the discussion around it in class. 

I think reading The American Dream as our first play really helped open our minds to the different meanings of literature. I know that it definitely helped me with Death of a Salesman. We watched the movie first, and that is not what we usually do. But doing that definitely helped with understanding the breaks from reality that Willy has. When I first saw the movie, I just thought that it was another story about a suburban family. Once we did the close reading, I realized how much more there was to a play. At first after only watching the movie my reaction to Willy was a combination of sympathy and pity. After the close reading it was a little pity and a lot of frustration. I was worried that near the end of my close reading I was going on a rant instead of analyzing the text. I pulled myself back from that. My reaction to Biff didn’t really change that much, I had sympathy for him. Then there was Happy, who I liked at first. But during the close reading he was driving me crazy with him -I’m not sure how to really even describe it- not having any substance. He really has no emotion, he is Willy all over again, and he saw his father die but he learned nothing from it. Happy is on the exact same path Willy was on. Then there is Linda, who was completely passive but also above Willy at the same time. It was frustrating that she would not confront Willy about his suicidal tendencies. I could sympathize with her in that a little though, I don’t think we know what we would do if we were put in her shoes.  I’m really looking forward to discussing the religious influences in the play. For example the pride that Willy has; that is considered one of the seven deadly sins. Another is jealousy that Charley (the only character other than Benard that I liked consistently) mentioned. 

Moving on from the emotional roller coaster. We discussed to poems in class, the first is My Father’s Song and the second is Promises Like Pie Crust. Poetry without a doubt is my weakest area in literature, but I think I’m improving. The first poem was interesting, we were able to dissect the poem with DIDLS, but struggled with meaning. I realized that I had the opposite problem, I understood the meaning, but DIDLS and the poetry terminology are more difficult for me. I know this is an area that I have to work at. I think I improved with the second poem, not by much but better than nothing. I really liked this poem, especially the metaphor. Ms. Holmes was gone during our hour and so was half of our class. That was a challenge for us and we needed time the next day to finish up. While discussing the theme of the poem, I realized that I had improved in dissecting poetry, but need to work on the terminology. I missed the day we did the multiple choice section on the poem. But I was there when we exchanged prompts. I really like that we keep practicing different ways for the AP exam. When we were working on the prompt, the thing that keeps tripping me up is the terminology used for poetry.
Then much earlier we worked on multiple choice questions. Not practice taking tests but understanding how they are written. I never realized that that much goes into writing a good multiple choice test. Writing our own multiple choice questions really helped to understand how they worked. Then taking different multiple choice tests, I saw how different distractors were used and I knew what types they were.  

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt 10/20/13

The 2004 open prompt was: Critic Roland Barthes has said, “Literature is the question minus the answer.” Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes’ observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author’s treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.


Student N:
Essay N is the best of the three essays without a doubt. The author starts the essay by addressing the question right away in the introduction. He/she chose to use Candide for the essay. They had a thesis and stuck with it. They use evidence to support the claims made and do a good job of tying everything back to the question. The student explains the plot of the novel but does so without summarizing. The organization was fairly simple and easy to follow. The essay did become a bit repetitive when he/she was discussing the phrase “tending our garden”. There are some grammatical errors that take away from the essay. The only other problems with the essay are that the lack of sophistication in the use of language and the syntax as mentioned previously has some mistakes. The author has a clear conclusion that ties back to his introduction. The essay successfully answers the prompt and that is the number one objective.
Student J:
The author of Essay J choose the very well known novel Adventures of Huckleberry Fin. The essay contained much more summarization than analysis. In the first paragraph, the introduction, the author has a clear thesis that addresses the prompt.  The second paragraph is mostly a summary of the book, it provides very little analysis. The third paragraph focuses more on the question, the first sentence in it goes back to the main question. The author unnecessarily goes into discussing what their issues with society, even though it addresses the complexities of the book. This would have been fine if the author had connected it back with the main focus of the essay.  They would have then strengthened the essay. The fourth paragraph discusses whether Huck and Jim were actually successful. It addresses the complexities of the issues they are dealing with, “Jim is still restricted by the conventions of modern society’s discrimination against blacks and Huck is restricted by the conventions of modern society, clothes and manners, against which he chafes”.  The sentence though sounds redundant. The essay would be much stronger if the author had tied back this paragraph with the main point of the essay. The conclusion tires  to tie everything together again. Overall the author barely answers the question without much deep analysis.  


Student U:
Essay U tries to answer the prompt by focusing on the novel Things Fall Apart. It received the lowest score of the three essays because it did not truly answer the prompt and mostly gave a summary of the novel. The essay consists of two paragraphs, this would not be that much of an issue if the ideas were well developed and supported but they are not. The structure does not help either. The first paragraph, the introduction, is spent on discussing the conflicts in the essay. The author develops a great question: “…does anything ever stay the same?” In the second paragraph of the essay, the author continues to discuss the conflicts within the novel, near the end of the paragraph the author tries to tie everything back to the question. In a way the author answers the prompt but it is nowhere near sufficient.  There is a significant lack of analysis in the essay.  There are no examples to support the essay, just claims that are poorly explained. Their main idea of the essay was a good one (the question), if the author had been able to expand on it and support it with examples the essay could have been great. Overall though the essay does not answer the prompt.  

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

The American Dream

The American Dream was written by Edward Albee, a playwright that lived during the 1900s.

Characters:
·         Grandma: Is the mother of mommy. She raised her by herself after her husband died. She is the only character that sees what is really happening in the play. She puts on an act that she is old and confused. In reality she is the wisest of them all in the play. She is often referred to as gender neutral and she exists outside the play. She is the old American Dream, with traditional values.
·         Mommy: Is Grandma’s daughter. She was manipulative even as a child and planned on marrying to become rich. She is the most dominant character in the play, she seeks control. She does not get along with Grandma.
·         Daddy: Is married to Mommy and is manipulated by her. He is the more feminine and maternal than her. He is wealthy and often sides with Grandma. He recently had a sex change.
·         Mrs. Barker: Is a professional woman. She is married and has two children. She the chairwomen of Mommy’s women’s club and volunteers for the Bye-Bye Adoption service. She sold Mommy and Daddy their child. She is in a power struggle with Mommy. Mommy and Daddy have called her back except they don’t remember why.
·         Young Man: Mommy and Daddy’s previous child (the bumble) was his twin who they mutilated and killed. As a result of his twin’s mutilation he is hallow and has no feelings. He is the very last character to arrive in the play. He is the new American Dream.

Setting:
·          The setting is an apartment in the 1950s, mainly in the living room.

Summary:
               Mommy, Daddy, and Grandma are introduced in the beginning of the play where Mommy establishes her dominance. Mommy fights with Grandma constantly and threatens her with the van-man. They are waiting for someone during all of this. Then Mrs. Barker arrives except she doesn’t know why she is here and neither Mommy nor Daddy remembers why she is here either. Grandma is the only one that knows why she is here. She tells Mrs. Barker the story “the bumble”, the child Mommy and Daddy adopted with Mrs. Barker’s help. Grandma tells the story of how Mommy and Daddy mutilate the child because it is human and has emotions. They have called Mrs. Barker for a replacement because they are not satisfied. Then the Young Man arrives, and Grandma talks to him. She realizes that he is the twin of the bumble. He has no emotions and is just a shell. She says that he is the American Dream and gives Mrs. Barker a solution to Mommy and Daddy’s need for satisfaction. The Young Man replaces Grandma as the American Dream. Grandma then addresses the audience.

Analysis:
                The play is in the point of view of the audience. The audience can see the interactions between the characters and is addressed by Grandma.  This is a result of her existing outside of the play. She is able to instruct the audience.
                The tone of the play is very childish overall. This is partially because of the character names, it is what the bumble and in the end the American Dream would have addressed the people as: Mommy, Daddy, Grandma, and Mrs. Barker. Mrs. Barker adds to this by not reacting like an adult when Grandma tells her the story about what happened to the bumble. Her reaction is pretty much no reaction. The exchanges between the different characters often seem like a conversation between children.
                Albee’s style as an author is fairly simple and general.  He does not give complicated stage directions and does not go into too many details about the characters. This is because he wants the “family” to be relatable. The setting is not unique, the names are not, and this lack of detail makes it possible for it to represent society in general.
                The main imagery in the play is the description of the mutilation of the child and the physical description of the American Dream. This is really interesting because they are supposed to be twins, and are foils for each other. The bumble had emotions and was mutilated as a result of Mommy and Daddy. This mutilation is also imagery, as Grandma describes it. Then there is imagery in the description of the American Dream, in that he looks perfect, even though he lacks actual substance. The reader can see them both in their mind. Then there is also imagery when Grandma is talking about what her daughter, Mommy, would say to her about marrying rich.
                There is a lot of symbolism in the play too. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream that is replaced. The Young Man symbolizes the new American Dream that is materialistic. Also the boxes Grandma has symbolize the old American values that they are filled up of.

Thesis:
Edward Albee’s The American Dream warns that the current generation of Americans have destroyed the substance of America that was the traditional values and replaced them with a materialistic longing to acquire momentary satisfaction but there is a possibility of change.
The very title of the play The American Dream is important. This is the central issue in the play the change in the American Dreams for different generations. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream, she has old values. Grandma had to work to support herself and Mommy after husband died. The Young Man symbolizes the new American Dream, which was declared by Grandma. He is willing to do anything for money and has no substance, he is hallow. Grandma and the Young Man can be foils for each other too. The Young Man that Grandma refers to as the American Dream is also the title of the play. The Young Man that is of the current generation, has no substance, in other words no values either.  This is part of the theme, the shift from Grandma to the Young Man’s American Dream.
The boxes that Grandma has packed neatly away symbolize the old American values that are packed away. It hurts Grandma to do this, “I didn’t like wrapping them; it hurt my fingers, and it frightened me” (71). When Grandma says this it does not make sense at first but one it is known that the boxes contain the values, it makes a lot more sense.  Grandma, the old generation, did not want to take the values, it hurt her, and frightened her thinking about what society would be left with then. Later Mommy steps all over Grandma’s boxes, in other words she steps on all the traditional values. This further shows the loss of traditional values among the current generation compared to the previous generations.
Near the end of the play the Young Man arrives at the door and Grandma opens it. He tells Grandma is story and she knows that he is the twin of the bumble. Grandma makes a plan for everybody to get “satisfaction” by replacing the bumble as Mommy and Daddy’s child, she tells Mrs. Barker of this and she announces it. The previous bumble had emotions and that is what Mommy and Daddy did not like. All they wanted was the outward appearance; this is the materialistic aspect of their American Dream. When the Young Man walk in Mommy’s reaction is: “Yes, sire! Yes, Sirree! Now this is more like it. Now this is a great deal more like it! Daddy! Come see. Come see if this isn’t a great deal more like it” (124). Mommy is finally satisfied with the child, it appears perfect and that is all that really matter to her and Daddy. Then Mrs. Barker criticizes the wine, show how temporary their happiness is. This shows this generation’s materialistic version of the American Dream and how it cannot last.
After Mommy, Daddy, Mrs. Barker, and the Young Man are “satisfied” for the time being. Grandma steps out of the play and she is able to escape their materialistic society. Grandma is not dead so she has a chance of coming back. Therefore the old American Dream is not permanently  gone it can still come back so there is hope.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading: If It Happened There . . . the Government Shutdown by Joshua Keating


In If It Happened There . . . the Government Shutdown, Joshua Keating discusses the then potential government shutdown similar to how American media would report on it in other countries. The essay looks at the different players in the shutdown: President Barack Obama, the Democratic Party, John Bohner, the Republican Party, and the Tea Party. Whenever an essay is written about anything, especially politics it is impossible to write it objectively. A reader’s response to it is also far from objective it is heavily based on their own views. Regardless of personal views, Keating uses diction, details, and imagery well to create a satiric essay that shows the hypocrisy and ridiculousness of the American government and the media.  
Keating’s word choice creates a sarcastic tone that shows the sharp contrast in the manner the media reports the news whether domestic or foreign. He also shows that the disagreement in D.C. is childish.  He refers to the different political parties as “rival clans”, this makes it seem like this whole problem of the government the shutdown is almost a game. “Rival clans” brings to mind what two opposing groups would be called in a video game. This may not seem significant but combined with the other word choices it helps create the tone and meaning. Keating then refers to Obama and to the executive branch as a “regime”, he could have easily referred to it as the executive branch. However that would not contributed to creating the tone and meaning. The word “regime” is used throughout the essay and it is associated with authoritarian forms of government and that is interpreted negatively in the U.S.   The word is used often by the media when reporting on the governments of foreign nations. The word choice shows how a person’s perspective on an issue needs to be taken into consideration. Referring to the different parties as “rival clans” gives the reader the idea that the whole shutdown is as childish as a game. The use of the word regime shows the difference in the way the media reports on different issues. The overall word choices by Keating help create the meaning of the essay.

Keating adds details that help convey the meaning behind the essay. In the third paragraph he mentions that one of the main causes the recent shutdown would be Obama care. This seems legitimate and does not seem to have much deeper meaning behind it but he then adds to the sentence, “to bring the nation’s health care system in line with international standards”. This now gives the reader the idea that what the fighting is over is absurd, in that Obama’s opposition does not have a legitimate argument. This furthers the idea that the fighting in D.C. is childish. Later in the article in the fifth paragraph, Keating describes what Ted Cruz did but it is not simply factual. He adds his thoughts on the situation by describing what Cruz did: “quoting liberally from the science fiction films and children’s books”. This gives the reader the idea that the whole deal with Cruz was childish and frankly pointless. Keating does not come out and directly say this but he is able to convey this through his use of details. Then one the reader considers how these two examples would be conveyed by the media if it had been taking place in another country helps further Keating’s main meaning. He uses details to show that the whole situation with the government shutdown and what lead up to it was immature and then continues to show the difference in the media’s perspectives.

Keating does not use a lot of imagery but the little that he does use is effective in creating a picture in the reader’s mind. In the introduction, Keating mentions that the then looming government shutdown was not apparent in D.C. He then goes on to say that, “Beret-wearing colonels have not yet taken to the airwaves to declare martial law”. The reader can picture this in their mind, but it is not a fear of the American people. This idea seems very far fetched to Americans but it would be how it is reported if a similar situation was taking place in another country. The idea would not seem far fetched for the image Keating described to take place in another country. This shows the difference in the way the media reports news and how it is interpreted. Keating uses imagery again in the last paragraph, “while driving down the poorly maintained roads that lead from the airport, “Do these guys have any idea what they’re  doing to the country?” This is a question that is asked by Keating’s cab driver. At this point the tone of the essay shifts a bit, it becomes more serious as he presents the reader the question whether the people in D.C. really know anything. The reader can picture themselves in the cab with Keating as driver mentions this.  This helps present the question to the reader and make the reader think about the message Keating is trying to convey throughout his essay. This is true for all the details he includes.

Keating uses diction, details, and imagery to convey his message that the then probable (now a reality) shutdown that was a result of disagreements is ridiculous and that the way the media portrays domestic issues differs from how they portray foreign issues. A case can be made for Keating being on Obama’s side and even on the Republican’s side. It depends on how you interpret the essay but his message does not change.




I had a lot of mixed reactions to the essay. When I first read it was really amusing and interesting, after looking more closely at it more closely it became clear that Keating was frustrated with the government and media. As I kept rereading it I would notice more of the little details that I might have missed the previous time I read it. I then thought of the personal bias that he must have when writing this essay and that that I also have in reading and responding to it. No matter your reaction the essay, it definitely makes you think about what is happening with the government and how the media portrays it.