Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material 11/24

I can’t believe that we’ve finished three plays already in class. We finished discussing Death of a Salesman, wrote a closed prompt to The Century Quilt, did mood and atmosphere exercises, and we finished Hamlet.

We spent a lot of time on Death of a Salesman, discussing it as a whole class, with the goldfish bowl, and then trying to make a theme statement. It was really interesting seeing people’s different reactions to Willy and how they changed as they did the close reading during the class discussions. The feelings ranged from hatred to pity and sympathy. I initially sympathized with Willy, but after I did the close reading most of sympathy was lost. Ms. Holmes had said that every time you read the play your reaction changes. I think this is because of the numerous ideas Miller tried to incorporate, some of them appear to be insufficiently developed or it could simply be there is so much going on in the play. For example one clear idea/motif in the play is the American Dream another less developed one is abandonment with Willy by Ben, his father, and his son Biff. It could also be that I simply noticed more while doing the close reading and especially because of watching the movie first. Books are typically much more descriptive and they don’t have to cut to a certain length like movies. I noticed this with other movies such Twilight, I read the book and then saw the movie. I noticed all the scenes that were left out. DOS is much shorter so all the crucial scenes were in it, but I certainly noticed more details when actually reading the play. I think this is probably one of the main reasons my reaction to Willy changed. We reached a theme statement for DOS faster than we did with The American Dream, probably because we knew what we were doing after creating a theme statement once. I’m sure the close reading of Hamlet will be harder than the previous plays, but we’ll also learn much more from it. We’re going to have a lot of discuss in class.

Next we wrote a closed prompt about the poem The Century Quilt. I thought that this was much harder than the closed readings that I do on the blog posts. I think this is because I typically do my closed prompts on news articles on politics and news needs to be easily comprehended. There is much more to look when analyzing the bias, but I don’t struggle with the structure or syntax as much as I did with the poem. I completely missed the way the poem was structured and how that was important. I’m going to try and vary what I do my close readings on and hopefully that will help. Another thing I struggled with while writing the closed prompt is timing. If Ms. Holmes could explain the whole poem during the AP exam and all I had to do was write about it, I would be good. I really struggled to be able to do both. By the time I started to understand some of the poem, I was running out of time. In a way the closed prompts remind me of the DBQs in APUSH and I had the same problem with them: timing. In a way the DBQs were easier because for half of the essay you were supposed to use outside information. For the closed prompts you have to understand the piece of literature to write any part of the essay.

The mood/atmosphere exercises do help with understanding the poems because it helps you learn different ways authors can create a mood without using the literal word that describes the mood. I noticed more and more how simple tense changes can change the mood and so can syntax. I think you also gain more appreciation to the process of writing and how much work some authors put into their work. I really enjoy the defense of the paragraph that we write because it explains how literary devices are used to create the mood/atmosphere. Hopefully this will help me understand a poem faster.

I was absent on the days we had the multiple choice practice and syntax exercise.


3 comments:

  1. Susheela,
    You clearly show understanding of what we've been doing in class at the end of October and beginning of November. However, I'm having trouble following your initial paragraph. You state "Ms. Holmes had said that every time you read the play your reaction changes. I think this is because DOS is one of those pieces of literature that you can keep reading and you find something new in it." which is essentially repeating the idea that Holmes has said. Acknowledging that the play changes with every read you give it, but then saying you think the play changes because you find something new in it isn't really giving a reason for why the play changes every time you read it. You continued to say that Miller incorporated so many ideas that some of them may be "undeveloped"--what ideas did Miller not develop enough? I found it interesting that your class made a theme statement for DOS faster than The American Dream, since I think my class was opposite. The American Dream, to me, was a much more simple play to understand and Albee made his assertions clear in his writing whereas Miller seemingly contradicted himself a lot of the time. It's also interesting that you connected the mood/atmosphere exercises with better understanding of poems--I never thought of it that way. Overall, nice response, but I think you should proof-read your writing once before sending it out to make sure everything makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great response, Susheela! You not only make a lot of thoughtful comments about our course material, but you discover strong connections between much of what were doing in class and your life outside the classroom. As far as I can tell, that's the whole point of the assignment, so great job! There are a few things you could add, however. For one, I think it would be beneficial to elaborate on Miller's ideas that you found to be underdeveloped. That could potentially reveal something new to the class that we haven't discussed yet, and originality is always desirable. I found your comparison between the closed prompt essays and our old APUSH DBQ's to be interesting. In terms of format, they're radically different, but I see what you're saying about timing. Both essays require a lot of understanding and planning before writing can even begin, so in that way they can pose as quite the challenge. I think "The Century Quilt" exercise and others like it will prove invaluable as we begin to really prepare for the AP exam. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Susheela,
    Great job on this response. I think you pretty much covered everything we did in this month and thoroughly explained what you thought of the activities. I completely agree with you on "The Century Quilt" because i too was way off in my analysis of it for the first time, maybe it was because of the timing issue and we need to learn to pace ourselves. Then again we're just learning and this is what the exercise is for right? I feel like this is great learn experience for us and realization of what's gonna be on the ap exam, So i do hope that Ms. Holmes would do more of these because the more practice the more we improve on doing them. You did a great response.

    ReplyDelete