In The White House's Website Still Says If You Like Your Plan You Can Keep It David Weigel discusses President Barack Obama’s interview with Chuck Todd, an NBC reporter. The article focuses on the interview and the current situation of Obamacare. It is practically impossible to report anything without bias. The degree of bias does differ, but it is possible to keep it to a minimum; most writers do attempt to do just that. Weigel utilizes diction, details, and syntax to mock the President’s interview, the “mainstream media”, and all of this makes his bias apparent.
Weigel’s clever word choice creates an amusing tone that mocks the President. To start within the very first paragraph Weigel describes that interview as about “the Obamacare Crisis”. The reader would know exactly what Weigel was talking about even without the word “Crisis” attached. However the word is important in creating the overall tone of the essay. The connotation behind the word crisis is not that it is merely a problem but one that is being handled poorly. The reader is given the impression that the President is not in control what is happening with Obamacare. In the next short paragraph Weigel goes on to ridicule the President’s apology; implying that is was insincere. The reader is given the idea that the president is similar to a child by claiming that “[it] took some coaxing for Todd to get the president to an apology”. The word “coaxing” brings to mind the idea of a child that made a mistake, but doesn’t want to admit to it. These two examples also show Weigel’s personal bias against the President and Obamacare. The portrayal of the President is not neutral but negative. The word choices by Weigel help him do this throughout the article.
The details included in the article assist in mocking the President and the “mainstream” media. Weigel starts the fourth paragraph of with mentioning that the President did not have a “policy response”. He focuses on what he considers to have been significantly lacking from the interview. Pointing this out would not have been significant if it were not for the rest of the sentence, “we get pain-feeling”. This gives the reader the impression that it was crucial for the President to have a policy response. It ignores the rest of the interview and what was discussed in it. It also implies that the President’s response was not sufficient. Later in the paragraph Weigel claims that that the whole apology was prompted by the media. He says that “[it’s] what the whole punditocracy demanded”. “Punditocracy” is not even a real word, but this detail is important because Weigel a stating that the media is hypocritical and mocking them for it. Then in the last paragraph he claims that that the whole situation with Obamacare was defendable “until the media decided it wasn’t”. This furthers the idea that the apology was a response to the “mainstream” media and it also ridicules the President for responding to the media that is hypocritical according the Weigel. Both of these details give the reader the impression that the media is inconsistent. Weigel uses details successfully to mock the President and “mainstream” media.
Syntax is also used well by Weigel. It is hard to miss his generous use of exclamation points. He uses them twice in the last paragraph: “They would have been worse off if they’d kept them! They haven’t considered their subsidies!” This is when Weigel is discussing the frustration of many people over losing their old health insurance; these are the excuses he claims the administration is making. The use of exclamation points gives the reader the impression that the President’s response are childish and trivial. He also utilizes short sentences to create emphasis for certain points. In the very first paragraph Weigel asks the question whether the President is actually regretful of what he said about Americans being able to keep their healthcare plans. Then he answers his own question with “He is!” The exclamation mark brings a sense of childishness back again but the short sentence creates emphasis on this childish undertone. The syntax used mocks the President as a result of the childish tone and it portrays the President negatively. This also shows Wiegal’s bias.
Diction, details, and syntax are used by Weigel help him mock the President, the “mainstream” media, and show his clear bias against them. Weigel’s personal views influence his interpretation of the interview. This article is well written regardless of the bias.
Other than the lack of some punctuation and the incorrect use of some punctuation, I feel that your close reading analysis was very well done Susheela. Your examples of the authors word choice and your explanations make it clear that the author really is biased, and biased toward not liking the President. However, in your second paragraph, you claim that the phrase "we get pain-feeling" in the article "implies that the President’s response was not sufficient"--how? There isn't sufficient evidence to back that claim up in your writing after the claim. Also, the author's use of the word "Punditocracy", I would argue, does not fall under the category of details, rather it falls under diction. Overall, I feel that your diction and syntax paragraphs are very well rounded, but your details paragraph lacks sufficient details and explanations of those details.
ReplyDeleteNice work Susheela. This post clearly showcases your knowledge of literary techniques and the ways in which they can create tone. Your intro sets up your argument with a distinct thesis statement that leaves no doubt as to what your essay will deal with. I find your examination of connotation with the word "crisis" to be spot on. However, I did find a few grammatical and spelling mistakes that would have been easy fixes with another proofread. Nothing too distracting, but a quick read-through would reduce the likelihood of technical mistakes detracting from the professionalism of your work. I love your analysis of the author's syntax. You were really able to dig deep into what can be the trickiest letter in the DIDLS acronym. The short sentence fragmentation you identified was a prime example, though one or two more pieces of evidence may have been helpful for supporting your claim. On top of that, your conclusion succinctly wrapped up your argument in a satisfying manner with a restatement of your thesis. Nice touch. Good stuff Susheela!
ReplyDeleteHey susheela,
ReplyDeleteOverall you did a great job on this close reading. I really like your paragraphs on diction and syntax. Especially in syntax when you had pointed out that the author uses short sentences to create emphasis, which I find that a lot of reporter have been doing. I think did very well on explaining why the author used the short sentence "He is!” However like what the others have said there were some grammatical errors that are very small and could have been fixed with a quick proof read. Just remember for next time. Anyways Great job on the close reading you clearly show that the author was biased.