Sunday, December 22, 2013

Response to Course Material: 12/22/13

We have spent all of our time focusing on Hamlet since the last response to course material post post. We read the play in class together, then watched parts of multiple versions of the movie, and read poems/articles on it. I missed the first day we started to read the play in class and that definitely made it all bit confusing. After we first read the play I had my own version of what the play was in my mind; watching different versions of Hamlet did change it.
It was interesting watching each version, they highlighted different things in the play. I really liked the setting for the Branaugh and Tennet versions. I thought that they both showed how there was always spying in Elsinore and the idea that there is something wrong there. Then I liked the casting in the Jacobi version compared to the other ones, especially for Laertes. I liked the casting in the Hawke version too, but Hawke’s Hamlet seemed to be monotone. He lacked the complexity that I personally think is  vital to Hamlet. His Hamlet just seemed really depressed and no other emotion was really apparent in the movie. I thought the movie had an interesting take on Laertes and Ophelia relationship that the others didn’t. The play in general reminds me of Death of a Salesman because of how you discover something new every time you read it or watch it again.  
I really enjoyed reading the articles on Hamlet, especially the one about the Tiv and their interpretation on the play Hamlet. It showed how subjective interpretations are and as a result the “true” meaning is too. The forum posts created a debate over whether there was a “correct” interpretation. I don’t think there is because everything is subjective and that includes whatever we personally think is the right version. This applies to other things too, from movies to music. Then the other two pieces on the forums were Rimbaud’s poem and the story about prisoners acting out Shakespeare. Rimbaud’s poem brought to mind who is really to blame for Ophelia’s death? Is there ever really anyone to to blame with suicide anyway? What about another Shakespeare play then, can anyone be blamed for Romeo and Juliet's death? The prisoners also showed Hamlet in a new light because they could connect with him in a way that we can’t.
We also had in class discussions over the play and the different versions of Hamlet that we watched. Someone made the analogy that if Hamlet was in a band he would be the lead singer, Horatio would be  the base player, Polonius would be the stage manager, the Queen and Ophelia would be groupies, and so on. I thought that this was funny, but it also did help with understanding the characters. As discussions continued we started to go more in depth, especially after our close reading. Another thing that came up was the Biblical references and parallels in play. Hamlet is typically considered the good guy, but it is hard to deny that there are parallels with him and Satan. Satan also tried to usurp God and that is what lead to him to being punished. He also started off as the good guy and it is apparent in the beginning of the play that he is good, but that changes as the play goes on. This comparison reminded me of Paradise Lost by Milton because of comparison with Satan and I learned the more about Satan after reading it last year in British Literature.
We also annotated Tragic Balance in Hamlet. I’m ended up being absent the day we discussed it in class, but I heard that it was a good discussion and I know that some of the classes really didn’t like it. My main issue was that the article was confusing because of all the ideas and it was difficult to tell which quotes were supporting the author or an older idea. It was still an interesting article though.

Thursday, December 12, 2013

Open Prompt: 2008 Question 3 12/15/13

2008 “The prompt for question 3, the “open” question, began by noting that in literary works, a minor character, often known as a foil, possesses traits that emphasize, by contrast or comparison, the distinctive characteristics and qualities of the main character. The prompt added that the ideas or behavior of the minor character might be used to highlight the weaknesses or strengths of the main character. Students were then asked to choose a novel or play in which a minor character serves as a foil to a main character and to write an essay analyzing how the relation between the minor character and the major character illuminates the meaning of the work as a whole”.
Essay 3A:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Joy Luck Club. One of the flaws of the essay is that the second and third paragraphs are mostly filled with plot summary. There is very little, if any, analysis in the paragraphs. This is clear when you first start to read the essay. The student received an 8, if they had more analysis with the summary and/or less summarization in the essay as a whole they probably could have gotten a 9.  The paragraph has a very good ending; it had a quote from the book and it helped wrap up the paragraph. The student had an adequate conclusion; it started with restating the thesis. Then ended with a strong and clear sentence: “Hung Taitai helped to highlight and emphasize all of Lindos good qualities”.  This sentence specifically answered the prompt, though it was less clear throughout the essay. It is a bit surprising that the essay received an 8 because it seemed to summarize too much, not focus on answering the prompt, and it didn’t have enough analysis. The essay did have a lot of evidence and a good introduction.
Essay 3B:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Color Purple. This was a fairly good essay overall. One problem that was noticeable early on was that the prompt was not answered early in the essay. Ideally the prompt would be answered in the first paragraph. It is only clear in the conclusion that the Celle’s father “serv(es) as her foil, he represents every characteristic that Celle learns not to be”. This is the only time that the prompt was directly answered and that was in the conclusion, which is late. The other issue with the essay is that there is more evidence for Shug to be Celle’s foil instead of her father in the essay. The student says that Celle was not independent and Shug is the opposite of that. This is discussed in the essay and it is unclear who the foil is till the end of the essay is. It received a 6 and I can understand why. The essay was fairly well written, but it was a bit confusing.
Essay 3C:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Kite Runner.  The student should try to vary his/her sentence structure more in the future. Majority of the sentences in the essay are fairly simple, “he emphasizes the good qualities in Hassan”. This would be fine if the short simple sentences were only used once in a while, especially to create emphasis. The problem is that they are common in the essay and as a result there is now flow. Also while some of the previous essays summarized too much, this one did not give a summary or background information on the plot much at all. This makes it difficult for someone who has not read the book to understand the essay. The student should also try to use more evidence and explain it. He/she did answer the prompt but not very well. The essay got a 4 and I agree with the score. The essay was underdeveloped, but it answered the prompt and has room for potential.


Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading: Inside the Box (12/8/13)

In the article Inside the Box Jessica Olien draws attention to how society adamantly claims that it loves creativity, but constantly shuns it. She explains how it is commonly unaccepted providing examples as evidence for her assertions. Then goes on to emphasize how it is under attack by society in numerous ways. Olien uses diction, syntax, and details to show how creativity is constantly praised, but in reality it is under attack by society.

Olien uses diction well to further her argument. In the first paragraph she refers to creativity as a “virtue” and a trait that is “celebrated”. This helps set a positive tone for the first paragraph because the word “virtue” and “celebrated” have good and happy connotations. These two words also give the reader the idea that creativity is very important. Later in the seventh paragraph Olien gives references the documentary The September Issue (about Vogue magazine), and she points out that the many ideas of the creative director are “reject(ed)” by Anna Wintour (editor-in-cheief). Olien does not simply say that the ideas are simply “reject(ed)”, but “systematically reject(ed)”. This is an important difference because of what the word “systematically” implies to the reader: that creativity is constantly denied and that this single example is universal. Olien’s word choice helps her convey her message to the reader.

While the tone of the first paragraph was positive, it came to a screeching halt in the second paragraph with one simple little sentence, “It’s all a lie”. The sentence is emphasized because of how short it is, especially compared to the rest of Olien’s sentences. It draws emphasis to the main idea of her article: that society claims to love creativity, but truly hate it. The sentence comes after what was discussed about diction in the first paragraph, so it also contrasts with that, and the short sentence emphasizes it because of how abrupt it is. She also uses hyphens to draw emphasis to other parts of the article. In the eleventh paragraph Olien highlights a “place where our first creative ideas go to die is the place that should be most open to them-schools”. The hyphen adds emphasis to the idea that schools hurt creativity, even though it is a long sentence. Olien utilizes syntax well to change the tone and add emphasis. All of this is to show how creativity is not widely valued and accepted, even though people think it is.

The details included in the article help Olien make her case. She includes a quote from Dave Hickey: “Everybody hates it when something’s really great”. This detail is significant because it reinforces the idea that creativity is great and that it is not accepted at once. The quote (in context) also implies that the reason behind creativity being rejected is people do not like success of others. This is a very negative concept and is used by Olien to strengthen her argument that creativity is rejected for terrible reasons. Then she shows the value of creativity by including the detail how “adults’ accomplishments are linked far more strongly to their creativity than their IQ” in the twelfth paragraph. The detail comes in the paragraph that continues to discus schools and as a result the detail implies that creativity should be fostered at school and should be more important than education. The details included in the article are used by Olien to stress the importance of creativity and draw attention to why it is often rejected.


Diction, syntax, and details are used well by Olien to show creativity is not accepted even though it is important and should be. She uses them to explain to the reader while people claim to value creativity it, it is not valued. Then goes on to say that for creativity to succeed one must be determined and not give up on it.  

Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material 11/24

I can’t believe that we’ve finished three plays already in class. We finished discussing Death of a Salesman, wrote a closed prompt to The Century Quilt, did mood and atmosphere exercises, and we finished Hamlet.

We spent a lot of time on Death of a Salesman, discussing it as a whole class, with the goldfish bowl, and then trying to make a theme statement. It was really interesting seeing people’s different reactions to Willy and how they changed as they did the close reading during the class discussions. The feelings ranged from hatred to pity and sympathy. I initially sympathized with Willy, but after I did the close reading most of sympathy was lost. Ms. Holmes had said that every time you read the play your reaction changes. I think this is because of the numerous ideas Miller tried to incorporate, some of them appear to be insufficiently developed or it could simply be there is so much going on in the play. For example one clear idea/motif in the play is the American Dream another less developed one is abandonment with Willy by Ben, his father, and his son Biff. It could also be that I simply noticed more while doing the close reading and especially because of watching the movie first. Books are typically much more descriptive and they don’t have to cut to a certain length like movies. I noticed this with other movies such Twilight, I read the book and then saw the movie. I noticed all the scenes that were left out. DOS is much shorter so all the crucial scenes were in it, but I certainly noticed more details when actually reading the play. I think this is probably one of the main reasons my reaction to Willy changed. We reached a theme statement for DOS faster than we did with The American Dream, probably because we knew what we were doing after creating a theme statement once. I’m sure the close reading of Hamlet will be harder than the previous plays, but we’ll also learn much more from it. We’re going to have a lot of discuss in class.

Next we wrote a closed prompt about the poem The Century Quilt. I thought that this was much harder than the closed readings that I do on the blog posts. I think this is because I typically do my closed prompts on news articles on politics and news needs to be easily comprehended. There is much more to look when analyzing the bias, but I don’t struggle with the structure or syntax as much as I did with the poem. I completely missed the way the poem was structured and how that was important. I’m going to try and vary what I do my close readings on and hopefully that will help. Another thing I struggled with while writing the closed prompt is timing. If Ms. Holmes could explain the whole poem during the AP exam and all I had to do was write about it, I would be good. I really struggled to be able to do both. By the time I started to understand some of the poem, I was running out of time. In a way the closed prompts remind me of the DBQs in APUSH and I had the same problem with them: timing. In a way the DBQs were easier because for half of the essay you were supposed to use outside information. For the closed prompts you have to understand the piece of literature to write any part of the essay.

The mood/atmosphere exercises do help with understanding the poems because it helps you learn different ways authors can create a mood without using the literal word that describes the mood. I noticed more and more how simple tense changes can change the mood and so can syntax. I think you also gain more appreciation to the process of writing and how much work some authors put into their work. I really enjoy the defense of the paragraph that we write because it explains how literary devices are used to create the mood/atmosphere. Hopefully this will help me understand a poem faster.

I was absent on the days we had the multiple choice practice and syntax exercise.


Friday, November 15, 2013

Open Prompt 11/17/13

2006 Open Prompt: A country setting is often used by many readers to establish values within a piece of literature. The country may be a place of virtue, peace, primitivism, and ignorance. Choose a novel or a play in which the country plays a significant role, and then write an essay analyzing how the country functions in the work as a whole.


Essay 3A:
The student choose to write an essay on Jane Austen’s Persuasion. The essay achieves its objective of explaining the significance of  the countryside to the novel. The introduction has a three pronged thesis that shows you exactly what the student will be addressing in the essay: “Although many writers may convey the countryside as a setting of ignorance and primitivism, Austen endows her countryside with nurturing, virtuous, and peaceful quality”. It would be better for purpose of organization if he/she mentioned the three different things they will be addressing in the order they’re planning to go about it. There are specific examples to support that are used by the student and that strengthens the essay. The final paragraph ties everything together and explains how the countryside is important for the protagonist’s development. This is specifically answers the prompt again. The essay was well written and organized overall. There were a few grammatical errors and abbreviations used in the essay. The organization not coinciding with the thesis was the only other noticeable flaw of the essay. Overall the essay accomplishes its objective well and that is why it received an 8. I agree with the score because it was well written, but it had some mistakes that would prevent it from receiving a 9.

Essay 3B:
The student chose to write an essay: The Importance of Being Earnest The first paragraph explains how the setting in the book contributed to the book. The paragraph also mentions the character, but it is unclear how the country setting relates to him. That hurts the essay because that is crucial to answering the prompt and should be clear from the get go. This is clearer in the next paragraph, where Jack “flees to the countryside”. Then the student goes off topic on comedic confusion and all it does is distract from the actual essay. In the final paragraph the student attempts to tie it all together, but is not able to because the essay goes off topic and did not directly address the prompt. Overall though the student did answer the prompt though it was very weak, with very little analysis provided to back up the claims made in the essay. The idea was good, but it definitely needs much more work as a result the student received a 6. I agree with the score because the student had a good idea, but didn’t execute it well.


Essay 3C:
The student choose to write his/her essay As I lay Dying. The introduction is short and the thesis states that the setting “dictates” the plot. The thesis and introduction would be stronger if the student just referred to the setting as the countryside, as was stated in the prompt. The student gives example throughout the essay, but never really ties it all together. The essay was more of a character explanation; this would have been fine if there was analysis on how the countryside affected them. The part of the countryside is practically left out of the response, and that is a big problem considering the fact that was pretty much the whole prompt. The student’s response barely addresses the prompt even indirectly, but there is a serious lack of thorough analysis, so it is not surprising that the student received a 3. I agree with the score and I think it would improve a lot if there was more in depth analysis and if the prompt was answered directly at least once.


Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Summary and Analysis: Death of a Salesman

Author: The play was written by Arthur Miller in 1949.

Setting: The setting of the play is New York and Boston. A lot of it takes place in the Loman family house.

Characters:
·         Willy: the father of Biff and Happy and the husband of Linda. He is a salesman, and he works for Howard. He had an older brother Ben, who he has delusions about. He sees himself as great and views his sons in the same light. Willy is also a compulsive liar that has become suicidal.
·         Biff: the eldest son of Willy. He was in jail; he had a problem with stealing even when he was younger. He was a star football player that had scholarship offers from universities. His future would of been Willy‘s definition of success. He worships his father, but everything crumbles (including his future) when he catches him cheating on his father.
·         Linda: is the wife of Willy and mother of Biff and Happy. She looks up to Willy and knows that he is thinking about taking his life. She is often submissive and weak to Willy, while in other areas she is the strong one in the relationship. She sides wants Biff to save Willy and says that he can’t only love her. She does not know about the affair.
·         Happy: is the youngest son of Willy. He very similar to Willy in character, family, and even occupation. Happy lies about his job, he is not as important as he makes himself seem. He also sleeps with women, including ones that are engaged. Happy doesn’t seem to have any emotions or dreams; he just takes from other’s.
·         Charlie: was Willy’s one true friend, even though Willy and he pretended to hate each other. He loans Willy $50 a week now for a long time it is because he doesn’t want Linda to know that he is on commission as a worker. He acts as if he doesn’t care about anything or anyone.
·         Bernard: Charlie’s son and a lawyer. He is Biff’s foil, he has a very respectable job, and he is very successful. He was Biff’s friend when he was younger and he would let Biff cheat off of him in school.
·         Ben: brother of Willy and uncle to Biff and Happy. He left for Alaska when Willy was young. He was successful and made a fortune.
·         Howard: Willy’s boss, he is the son of the former man Willy worked for. Howard inherited all of his money; he didn’t have to work for it. He eventually fires Willy.
·         The Women: the women Willy has an affair with.

Summary:
The play starts off with Willy returning from a trip back home. He has been demoted at work so now he is working on commission. Biff and Happy are home too and whenever Biff is there Willy starts acting strange. He is having flashbacks about Ben, when Biff was younger, and before he had the affair. Willy starts to flashback to when he was with The Women and she is laughing and he has given her stockings. Seeing Linda mend stockings makes Willy mad because it reminds him of the affair. Biff and Happy talk to Linda about Willy’s condition after they hear him yelling outside.  Biff says he is going to talk to Oliver, someone that supposedly liked him in high school. This is partly because of encouragement from him. Willy is temporarily Happy about this and the thought of the boys taking him to dinner. While leading up to the dinner Willy losses his job and then runs into Bernard at Charlie’s. He turns down the job Charlie offers for the sake of pride.  Biff and Happy get to the restaurant and Biff tells Happy that he ran out with Oliver’s pen. Then it all hit him (reality) that he could be happy without it all. Also Oliver didn’t remember who he was and when Biff tells Happy that he says that he should lie to their father. Biff does end up lying to Willy but it’s with the best intentions. Then Willy flashes back to when Biff finds him with The Women. This is from when everything goes south. Happy and Biff leave Willy there and leave with girls. Linda is furious and she has a fight with her sons. Happy who wants to pretend everything is great and Biff who feels that he can’t save his father. Biff ends up crying staring at Willy and he realizes that his son does love him. Willy has been contemplating suicide for a while and now that he knows the Biff does love him he sees no reason to wait any longer. He kills himself for the insurance money. The play ends with Linda, Biff, Happy, Charlie, and Bernard all at Willy’s funeral; that is unattended by others. Biff condemns Willy’s actions while Happy decides to take the same path.  

Analysis:
The play is not really in anybody’s point of view other than the audience. This is because it is a play and there really isn’t any narration. A case can be made though that the play is in the point of view of Willy because the audience is able to watch his delusions/flashbacks.   
The tone of the play is mellow and tense.  This is created by multiple aspects of the play, Willy being out of touch with reality, Biff not really having a future, Happy lack of a personality, and one of the most important is the relationship between Linda and Willy. It is abusive and Willy typically takes Linda for granted. This creates a negative image of one of the central characters. Then the arguments that arise out of thin air where for example when Willy feels insulted. This creates a tense atmosphere. There is a case that can be made for Death of a Salesman being a tragedy and this tone would go along with that.
Miller’s style as an author is fairly simple and to the point. That does not mean that there aren’t much deeper meanings, there are. His style is simple so that an average reader or audience member can understand the play. It is already confusing to some with the flash backs and delusions that Willy has. His style makes it easier for the viewer to comprehend the play. Miller is doesn’t use elevated diction, he want the viewer to understand the play.
The imagery in the play is often of nature, such as trees or the jungle. These are also motifs that keep appearing in the play. There is imagery that is created by the stage directions. For example the flute playing, this reminds Willy of his father. Miller also uses imagery to describe Willy and Biff. In the opening of act 1, Willy is described as “sixty years of age, dressed quietly”; the reader can picture Willy entering his house(12). Then Miller goes on to describe Biff as “well built”, that is important because his future (at least what they all imagined in the past) was playing football.  
            There are numerous symbols in the play from the seeds that Willy is determined to plant to the stockings that he gave to The Women. The seeds symbolize Willy’s sons and the future. Willy tries to plant seeds and help them grow but he is not able to similar to raising his children. He tries to make them great but is not able to that either. Then the stockings remind Willy of his infidelity, that some would blame as the cause of Biff ruining his future. This is why Willy become upset every time he sees Linda with her stockings, they remind of the affair. Another symbol in the play is diamonds; they symbolize Ben’s success and contrast to show Willy’s lack thereof. Diamonds are mentioned repeatedly by Willy.
           
Quotes:
            There are many scenes that are important and significant in the play. One is when Willy is talking to Charlie and he says “After all the highways, and the trains, and the appointments, and the years, you end up worth more dead than alive”. Willy is talking about his life insurance that his family will receive. In his mind he is now worth more dead. This is when Willy is re contemplating suicide. The viewer/reader knows that this time there is a chance that Willy will actually take his life. It is foreshadowing by Miller of Willy’s coming death.
            Another important quote from the book is “I’m going to show you and everybody else that Willy Loman did not die in vain”. This is what Happy says to Biff at the funeral. This shows that he is very similar to Willy, while Biff is very different. It also shows that Happy has not learned from Willy’s life and his death. Biff has learned from his death though. Happy is going to follow Willy’s life path.


Theme:
 Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman suggests that valuing words instead of actions leads to a delusional perception of one’s conventional success; that results in the deterioration of family and one’s self.

This theme is supported by the plot. Willy is a compulsive liar similar to Happy; this shows how he values words over actions. When Howard is firing Willy says that “there were promises made across this desk”. He is trying to hold Howard accountable for what he believes his father promised him. Then the very occupation Willy is in supports this theme: salesman try to make a sale, that’s what they try to do. Words are more important than action to them. All of this is what leads to the destruction of his family and his very life. Willy fills Biff with the same values and then when Biff sees his father’s fall from grace he is destroyed. Then Willy believes that what people say about him and who shows up at the funeral are more important than his life (action). All leading to his death.  

 

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Close Reading: The White House's Website Still Says If You Like Your Plan You Can Keep It (11/10)

              In The White House's Website Still Says If You Like Your Plan You Can Keep It David Weigel discusses President Barack Obama’s interview with Chuck Todd, an NBC reporter. The article focuses on the interview and the current situation of Obamacare. It is practically impossible to report anything without bias. The degree of bias does differ, but it is possible to keep it to a minimum; most writers do attempt to do just that. Weigel utilizes diction, details, and syntax to mock the President’s interview, the “mainstream media”, and all of this makes his bias apparent.
 
        Weigel’s clever word choice creates an amusing tone that mocks the President. To start within the very first paragraph Weigel describes that interview as about “the Obamacare Crisis”. The reader would know exactly what Weigel was talking about even without the word “Crisis” attached. However the word is important in creating the overall tone of the essay. The connotation behind the word crisis is not that it is merely a problem but one that is being handled poorly. The reader is given the impression that the President is not in control what is happening with Obamacare. In the next short paragraph Weigel goes on to ridicule the President’s apology; implying that is was insincere. The reader is given the idea that the president is similar to a child by claiming that “[it] took some coaxing for Todd to get the president to an apology”. The word “coaxing” brings to mind the idea of a child that made a mistake, but doesn’t want to admit to it. These two examples also show Weigel’s personal bias against the President and Obamacare. The portrayal of the President is not neutral but negative. The word choices by Weigel help him do this throughout the article.
        The details included in the article assist in mocking the President and the “mainstream” media. Weigel starts the fourth paragraph of with mentioning that the President did not have a “policy response”. He focuses on what he considers to have been significantly lacking from the interview. Pointing this out would not have been significant if it were not for the rest of the sentence, “we get pain-feeling”. This gives the reader the impression that it was crucial for the President to have a policy response. It ignores the rest of the interview and what was discussed in it. It also implies that the President’s response was not sufficient. Later in the paragraph Weigel claims that that the whole apology was prompted by the media. He says that “[it’s] what the whole punditocracy demanded”. “Punditocracy” is not even a real word, but this detail is important because Weigel a stating that the media is hypocritical and mocking them for it. Then in the last paragraph he claims that that the whole situation with Obamacare was defendable “until the media decided it wasn’t”. This furthers the idea that the apology was a response to the “mainstream” media and it also ridicules the President for responding to the media that is hypocritical according the Weigel. Both of these details give the reader the impression that the media is inconsistent. Weigel uses details successfully to mock the President and “mainstream” media.
        Syntax is also used well by Weigel. It is hard to miss his generous use of exclamation points. He uses them twice in the last paragraph: “They would have been worse off if they’d kept them! They haven’t considered their subsidies!” This is when Weigel is discussing the frustration of many people over losing their old health insurance; these are the excuses he claims the administration is making. The use of exclamation points gives the reader the impression that the President’s response are childish and trivial. He also utilizes short sentences to create emphasis for certain points. In the very first paragraph Weigel asks the question whether the President is actually regretful of what he said about Americans being able to keep their healthcare plans. Then he answers his own question with “He is!” The exclamation mark brings a sense of childishness back again but the short sentence creates emphasis on this childish undertone. The syntax used mocks the President as a result of the childish tone and it portrays the President negatively. This also shows Wiegal’s bias.
        Diction, details, and syntax are used by Weigel help him mock the President, the “mainstream” media, and show his clear bias against them. Weigel’s personal views influence his interpretation of the interview. This article is well written regardless of the bias.

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material 10/27/2013

Over the last couple of weeks we finished The American Dream, went over multiple choice question, discussed poetry, started Death of  a Salesman. This is a lot of information that we have covered.

I really love that we read the plays and have so much time to discuss in class. It really helps you dig into a novel or play. We finished our discussions of The American Dream, and we had to write a theme statement for it. I struggled to include all the different parts of the play in that statement. One thing that I learned was that I don’t need to include every little details in the theme statement. I also realized that before sometime I would pull out a motif as the theme.
When we discussed the theme as a class there was some disagreement over it. We finally settled on a theme, but I changed a few aspects of it. I really like this, the fact that we weren’t limited to one theme as a class, but we also were allowed to use the same one if we all agreed upon it. The idea of having to write a full theme statement on my own is a bit daunting, but it really helped to hear all the discussion around it in class. 

I think reading The American Dream as our first play really helped open our minds to the different meanings of literature. I know that it definitely helped me with Death of a Salesman. We watched the movie first, and that is not what we usually do. But doing that definitely helped with understanding the breaks from reality that Willy has. When I first saw the movie, I just thought that it was another story about a suburban family. Once we did the close reading, I realized how much more there was to a play. At first after only watching the movie my reaction to Willy was a combination of sympathy and pity. After the close reading it was a little pity and a lot of frustration. I was worried that near the end of my close reading I was going on a rant instead of analyzing the text. I pulled myself back from that. My reaction to Biff didn’t really change that much, I had sympathy for him. Then there was Happy, who I liked at first. But during the close reading he was driving me crazy with him -I’m not sure how to really even describe it- not having any substance. He really has no emotion, he is Willy all over again, and he saw his father die but he learned nothing from it. Happy is on the exact same path Willy was on. Then there is Linda, who was completely passive but also above Willy at the same time. It was frustrating that she would not confront Willy about his suicidal tendencies. I could sympathize with her in that a little though, I don’t think we know what we would do if we were put in her shoes.  I’m really looking forward to discussing the religious influences in the play. For example the pride that Willy has; that is considered one of the seven deadly sins. Another is jealousy that Charley (the only character other than Benard that I liked consistently) mentioned. 

Moving on from the emotional roller coaster. We discussed to poems in class, the first is My Father’s Song and the second is Promises Like Pie Crust. Poetry without a doubt is my weakest area in literature, but I think I’m improving. The first poem was interesting, we were able to dissect the poem with DIDLS, but struggled with meaning. I realized that I had the opposite problem, I understood the meaning, but DIDLS and the poetry terminology are more difficult for me. I know this is an area that I have to work at. I think I improved with the second poem, not by much but better than nothing. I really liked this poem, especially the metaphor. Ms. Holmes was gone during our hour and so was half of our class. That was a challenge for us and we needed time the next day to finish up. While discussing the theme of the poem, I realized that I had improved in dissecting poetry, but need to work on the terminology. I missed the day we did the multiple choice section on the poem. But I was there when we exchanged prompts. I really like that we keep practicing different ways for the AP exam. When we were working on the prompt, the thing that keeps tripping me up is the terminology used for poetry.
Then much earlier we worked on multiple choice questions. Not practice taking tests but understanding how they are written. I never realized that that much goes into writing a good multiple choice test. Writing our own multiple choice questions really helped to understand how they worked. Then taking different multiple choice tests, I saw how different distractors were used and I knew what types they were.  

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt 10/20/13

The 2004 open prompt was: Critic Roland Barthes has said, “Literature is the question minus the answer.” Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes’ observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author’s treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.


Student N:
Essay N is the best of the three essays without a doubt. The author starts the essay by addressing the question right away in the introduction. He/she chose to use Candide for the essay. They had a thesis and stuck with it. They use evidence to support the claims made and do a good job of tying everything back to the question. The student explains the plot of the novel but does so without summarizing. The organization was fairly simple and easy to follow. The essay did become a bit repetitive when he/she was discussing the phrase “tending our garden”. There are some grammatical errors that take away from the essay. The only other problems with the essay are that the lack of sophistication in the use of language and the syntax as mentioned previously has some mistakes. The author has a clear conclusion that ties back to his introduction. The essay successfully answers the prompt and that is the number one objective.
Student J:
The author of Essay J choose the very well known novel Adventures of Huckleberry Fin. The essay contained much more summarization than analysis. In the first paragraph, the introduction, the author has a clear thesis that addresses the prompt.  The second paragraph is mostly a summary of the book, it provides very little analysis. The third paragraph focuses more on the question, the first sentence in it goes back to the main question. The author unnecessarily goes into discussing what their issues with society, even though it addresses the complexities of the book. This would have been fine if the author had connected it back with the main focus of the essay.  They would have then strengthened the essay. The fourth paragraph discusses whether Huck and Jim were actually successful. It addresses the complexities of the issues they are dealing with, “Jim is still restricted by the conventions of modern society’s discrimination against blacks and Huck is restricted by the conventions of modern society, clothes and manners, against which he chafes”.  The sentence though sounds redundant. The essay would be much stronger if the author had tied back this paragraph with the main point of the essay. The conclusion tires  to tie everything together again. Overall the author barely answers the question without much deep analysis.  


Student U:
Essay U tries to answer the prompt by focusing on the novel Things Fall Apart. It received the lowest score of the three essays because it did not truly answer the prompt and mostly gave a summary of the novel. The essay consists of two paragraphs, this would not be that much of an issue if the ideas were well developed and supported but they are not. The structure does not help either. The first paragraph, the introduction, is spent on discussing the conflicts in the essay. The author develops a great question: “…does anything ever stay the same?” In the second paragraph of the essay, the author continues to discuss the conflicts within the novel, near the end of the paragraph the author tries to tie everything back to the question. In a way the author answers the prompt but it is nowhere near sufficient.  There is a significant lack of analysis in the essay.  There are no examples to support the essay, just claims that are poorly explained. Their main idea of the essay was a good one (the question), if the author had been able to expand on it and support it with examples the essay could have been great. Overall though the essay does not answer the prompt.  

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

The American Dream

The American Dream was written by Edward Albee, a playwright that lived during the 1900s.

Characters:
·         Grandma: Is the mother of mommy. She raised her by herself after her husband died. She is the only character that sees what is really happening in the play. She puts on an act that she is old and confused. In reality she is the wisest of them all in the play. She is often referred to as gender neutral and she exists outside the play. She is the old American Dream, with traditional values.
·         Mommy: Is Grandma’s daughter. She was manipulative even as a child and planned on marrying to become rich. She is the most dominant character in the play, she seeks control. She does not get along with Grandma.
·         Daddy: Is married to Mommy and is manipulated by her. He is the more feminine and maternal than her. He is wealthy and often sides with Grandma. He recently had a sex change.
·         Mrs. Barker: Is a professional woman. She is married and has two children. She the chairwomen of Mommy’s women’s club and volunteers for the Bye-Bye Adoption service. She sold Mommy and Daddy their child. She is in a power struggle with Mommy. Mommy and Daddy have called her back except they don’t remember why.
·         Young Man: Mommy and Daddy’s previous child (the bumble) was his twin who they mutilated and killed. As a result of his twin’s mutilation he is hallow and has no feelings. He is the very last character to arrive in the play. He is the new American Dream.

Setting:
·          The setting is an apartment in the 1950s, mainly in the living room.

Summary:
               Mommy, Daddy, and Grandma are introduced in the beginning of the play where Mommy establishes her dominance. Mommy fights with Grandma constantly and threatens her with the van-man. They are waiting for someone during all of this. Then Mrs. Barker arrives except she doesn’t know why she is here and neither Mommy nor Daddy remembers why she is here either. Grandma is the only one that knows why she is here. She tells Mrs. Barker the story “the bumble”, the child Mommy and Daddy adopted with Mrs. Barker’s help. Grandma tells the story of how Mommy and Daddy mutilate the child because it is human and has emotions. They have called Mrs. Barker for a replacement because they are not satisfied. Then the Young Man arrives, and Grandma talks to him. She realizes that he is the twin of the bumble. He has no emotions and is just a shell. She says that he is the American Dream and gives Mrs. Barker a solution to Mommy and Daddy’s need for satisfaction. The Young Man replaces Grandma as the American Dream. Grandma then addresses the audience.

Analysis:
                The play is in the point of view of the audience. The audience can see the interactions between the characters and is addressed by Grandma.  This is a result of her existing outside of the play. She is able to instruct the audience.
                The tone of the play is very childish overall. This is partially because of the character names, it is what the bumble and in the end the American Dream would have addressed the people as: Mommy, Daddy, Grandma, and Mrs. Barker. Mrs. Barker adds to this by not reacting like an adult when Grandma tells her the story about what happened to the bumble. Her reaction is pretty much no reaction. The exchanges between the different characters often seem like a conversation between children.
                Albee’s style as an author is fairly simple and general.  He does not give complicated stage directions and does not go into too many details about the characters. This is because he wants the “family” to be relatable. The setting is not unique, the names are not, and this lack of detail makes it possible for it to represent society in general.
                The main imagery in the play is the description of the mutilation of the child and the physical description of the American Dream. This is really interesting because they are supposed to be twins, and are foils for each other. The bumble had emotions and was mutilated as a result of Mommy and Daddy. This mutilation is also imagery, as Grandma describes it. Then there is imagery in the description of the American Dream, in that he looks perfect, even though he lacks actual substance. The reader can see them both in their mind. Then there is also imagery when Grandma is talking about what her daughter, Mommy, would say to her about marrying rich.
                There is a lot of symbolism in the play too. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream that is replaced. The Young Man symbolizes the new American Dream that is materialistic. Also the boxes Grandma has symbolize the old American values that they are filled up of.

Thesis:
Edward Albee’s The American Dream warns that the current generation of Americans have destroyed the substance of America that was the traditional values and replaced them with a materialistic longing to acquire momentary satisfaction but there is a possibility of change.
The very title of the play The American Dream is important. This is the central issue in the play the change in the American Dreams for different generations. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream, she has old values. Grandma had to work to support herself and Mommy after husband died. The Young Man symbolizes the new American Dream, which was declared by Grandma. He is willing to do anything for money and has no substance, he is hallow. Grandma and the Young Man can be foils for each other too. The Young Man that Grandma refers to as the American Dream is also the title of the play. The Young Man that is of the current generation, has no substance, in other words no values either.  This is part of the theme, the shift from Grandma to the Young Man’s American Dream.
The boxes that Grandma has packed neatly away symbolize the old American values that are packed away. It hurts Grandma to do this, “I didn’t like wrapping them; it hurt my fingers, and it frightened me” (71). When Grandma says this it does not make sense at first but one it is known that the boxes contain the values, it makes a lot more sense.  Grandma, the old generation, did not want to take the values, it hurt her, and frightened her thinking about what society would be left with then. Later Mommy steps all over Grandma’s boxes, in other words she steps on all the traditional values. This further shows the loss of traditional values among the current generation compared to the previous generations.
Near the end of the play the Young Man arrives at the door and Grandma opens it. He tells Grandma is story and she knows that he is the twin of the bumble. Grandma makes a plan for everybody to get “satisfaction” by replacing the bumble as Mommy and Daddy’s child, she tells Mrs. Barker of this and she announces it. The previous bumble had emotions and that is what Mommy and Daddy did not like. All they wanted was the outward appearance; this is the materialistic aspect of their American Dream. When the Young Man walk in Mommy’s reaction is: “Yes, sire! Yes, Sirree! Now this is more like it. Now this is a great deal more like it! Daddy! Come see. Come see if this isn’t a great deal more like it” (124). Mommy is finally satisfied with the child, it appears perfect and that is all that really matter to her and Daddy. Then Mrs. Barker criticizes the wine, show how temporary their happiness is. This shows this generation’s materialistic version of the American Dream and how it cannot last.
After Mommy, Daddy, Mrs. Barker, and the Young Man are “satisfied” for the time being. Grandma steps out of the play and she is able to escape their materialistic society. Grandma is not dead so she has a chance of coming back. Therefore the old American Dream is not permanently  gone it can still come back so there is hope.

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading: If It Happened There . . . the Government Shutdown by Joshua Keating


In If It Happened There . . . the Government Shutdown, Joshua Keating discusses the then potential government shutdown similar to how American media would report on it in other countries. The essay looks at the different players in the shutdown: President Barack Obama, the Democratic Party, John Bohner, the Republican Party, and the Tea Party. Whenever an essay is written about anything, especially politics it is impossible to write it objectively. A reader’s response to it is also far from objective it is heavily based on their own views. Regardless of personal views, Keating uses diction, details, and imagery well to create a satiric essay that shows the hypocrisy and ridiculousness of the American government and the media.  
Keating’s word choice creates a sarcastic tone that shows the sharp contrast in the manner the media reports the news whether domestic or foreign. He also shows that the disagreement in D.C. is childish.  He refers to the different political parties as “rival clans”, this makes it seem like this whole problem of the government the shutdown is almost a game. “Rival clans” brings to mind what two opposing groups would be called in a video game. This may not seem significant but combined with the other word choices it helps create the tone and meaning. Keating then refers to Obama and to the executive branch as a “regime”, he could have easily referred to it as the executive branch. However that would not contributed to creating the tone and meaning. The word “regime” is used throughout the essay and it is associated with authoritarian forms of government and that is interpreted negatively in the U.S.   The word is used often by the media when reporting on the governments of foreign nations. The word choice shows how a person’s perspective on an issue needs to be taken into consideration. Referring to the different parties as “rival clans” gives the reader the idea that the whole shutdown is as childish as a game. The use of the word regime shows the difference in the way the media reports on different issues. The overall word choices by Keating help create the meaning of the essay.

Keating adds details that help convey the meaning behind the essay. In the third paragraph he mentions that one of the main causes the recent shutdown would be Obama care. This seems legitimate and does not seem to have much deeper meaning behind it but he then adds to the sentence, “to bring the nation’s health care system in line with international standards”. This now gives the reader the idea that what the fighting is over is absurd, in that Obama’s opposition does not have a legitimate argument. This furthers the idea that the fighting in D.C. is childish. Later in the article in the fifth paragraph, Keating describes what Ted Cruz did but it is not simply factual. He adds his thoughts on the situation by describing what Cruz did: “quoting liberally from the science fiction films and children’s books”. This gives the reader the idea that the whole deal with Cruz was childish and frankly pointless. Keating does not come out and directly say this but he is able to convey this through his use of details. Then one the reader considers how these two examples would be conveyed by the media if it had been taking place in another country helps further Keating’s main meaning. He uses details to show that the whole situation with the government shutdown and what lead up to it was immature and then continues to show the difference in the media’s perspectives.

Keating does not use a lot of imagery but the little that he does use is effective in creating a picture in the reader’s mind. In the introduction, Keating mentions that the then looming government shutdown was not apparent in D.C. He then goes on to say that, “Beret-wearing colonels have not yet taken to the airwaves to declare martial law”. The reader can picture this in their mind, but it is not a fear of the American people. This idea seems very far fetched to Americans but it would be how it is reported if a similar situation was taking place in another country. The idea would not seem far fetched for the image Keating described to take place in another country. This shows the difference in the way the media reports news and how it is interpreted. Keating uses imagery again in the last paragraph, “while driving down the poorly maintained roads that lead from the airport, “Do these guys have any idea what they’re  doing to the country?” This is a question that is asked by Keating’s cab driver. At this point the tone of the essay shifts a bit, it becomes more serious as he presents the reader the question whether the people in D.C. really know anything. The reader can picture themselves in the cab with Keating as driver mentions this.  This helps present the question to the reader and make the reader think about the message Keating is trying to convey throughout his essay. This is true for all the details he includes.

Keating uses diction, details, and imagery to convey his message that the then probable (now a reality) shutdown that was a result of disagreements is ridiculous and that the way the media portrays domestic issues differs from how they portray foreign issues. A case can be made for Keating being on Obama’s side and even on the Republican’s side. It depends on how you interpret the essay but his message does not change.




I had a lot of mixed reactions to the essay. When I first read it was really amusing and interesting, after looking more closely at it more closely it became clear that Keating was frustrated with the government and media. As I kept rereading it I would notice more of the little details that I might have missed the previous time I read it. I then thought of the personal bias that he must have when writing this essay and that that I also have in reading and responding to it. No matter your reaction the essay, it definitely makes you think about what is happening with the government and how the media portrays it. 


Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response To Course Material 9/29

In these first couple of weeks in class we have covered multiple topics from Edward Albee’s The American Dream to AP writing prompts. All of the things we have covered so far tie together.


We started of learning how to annotate, with DIDILS (diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax). I realized that in previous classes that I had noticed and discussed components of this, even if I hadn't formally really annotated. This also gave me insight on my own writing.

We started off by focusing on diction and syntax, we looked at the diction of two excerpts. Then moved on to syntax, we received the handout Syntax as Style. We started of by taking small steps, first we saw examples (in the handout) on how syntax was used and had to apply it with a partner to one of the excerpts in the handout. This exercise really helped me, I struggled at first with it because my partner and I had picked Henry David Thoreau’s Walden and I wasn't used to the writing. Thoreau uses long sentences that flow well to create calm tone. I think struggling with this helped me in the end.


Imagery, another part of DIDLS, was a part I was very familiar with. We had discussed it in many of my previous classes. It is used very commonly to help convey meaning because it  appeals to the five senses. Imagery can be as simple as “It was a warm summer day”, the reader must be able to “see”, “feel”, “taste”, and “smell” what the author is describing.


When I first heard that details was part of DIDLS, I didn't really understand it. I thought everything was details, so what do you mean focus on the details? Now I understand how small details can make a difference. I also struggled with differentiating diction and language. I was sure how diction was really different from language. I learned that diction is more of a focus on isolated words, while language focuses on the whole.


We used the different components of DIDLS for the closed reading. I used an article from Slate, my first reaction to it was that I thought it was fairly well written and a good article. While focusing on the diction, details, and syntax, I started to disagree with the author and didn't like the tone the diction created. I was surprised that by the end of my close reading I had the opposite response to my initial one.


The close reading helped with learning how to annotate and it also helped with the AP writing we did in class. The open reading did the same except it was much more direct.I realized that some of the common mistakes that students make when writing responses to the prompts are similar to ones I have made before. Instead of actually responding to the question, you end up summarizing. I still thought that the writing we did in class was hard though but it gave me a good heads up on what to expect on the actual exam and in class. I think that there are significant differences between prompts that you can pick the literature for and other that have already assigned it.

All the parts of DIDLS, came together again when we read The American Dream. It is still debated the true meaning of the play. It was a fast read, and it allowed us to cover multiple topics in it. We received the handout Existentialism 101, once I understood what existentialism was I thought about what we had been learning in AP Government different philosophers from Locke to Plato. We also discussed Thomas Hobbes’s theories on government and people. I thought some of it was similar to existentialists. Existentialists believe that “there are no ‘universal’ guidelines”, Hobbes had a similar view. He thought that there weren't any rules or morals in a state of nature that regulated people’s actions. We also received a handout  on Theater of the Absurd, I thought this was really interesting to learn about. It was not something that I had much prior knowledge about. The American Dream is considered theater of the absurd. The way of thinking is cynical but it is hard to deny some of the truth, no matter how much it would please many to do so; it had a realistic approach. It was also really helpful to read different perspectives on The American Dream. Then we looked at the theories of comedy and the different types of them. I think comedies are very interesting and complicated when you look into specifics of them.  I knew there we different types of comedies but I never knew there were so many of them. There are many parodies out there, almost everybody has read and/or seen Twilight, but there are also parodies of it: Nightlight and Vampires Sucks. You can see how different forms of comedy is used and its purpose. 

The American Dream

  • We spent most of our time on The American Dream. The handouts that we received helped but just asking question and discussing is what I thought was the most useful personally. I personally like assignments that tell me exactly what to do and have one answer. I found the The American Dream a bit frustrating in that sense. Discussing the meaning was very interesting and I learned a lot form it. I thought that it also incorporated our summer work, Foster's book, on the meaning behind everything with it. For example sex isn't really just that, there is more meaning behind. This might be difficult for some to understand but in the play what is really shows is the lack of intimacy. Yes there is physical intimacy but there isn't any emotional intimacy or any real relationships.
  • When I first read this play I thought it was quite amusing. My thoughts on it completely changed after discussing it. When I read the scene with Grandma telling Mrs. Barker the story of the Bumble, I was shocked at first for sure. However I didn't fully grasp how dark it was. That scene had just confused me at first. 
  • Another interesting aspect was trying to classify The American Dream as a type of comedy after we received that handout. It was funny, at least at first, so almost everybody agreed that it was a comedy. The only disagreement was on why type. Some thought that it was high comedy, because the play appealed to people's intellect. I disagreed with this and so did some of my peers. High comedy appeals to the intellect but it is only funny if you can understand this appeal. Considering I had to disagree that The American Dream was high comedy. Once you look beyond the surface of the The American Dream, in other words try to understand the deeper meanings, ideas, and motifs; all the humor is thrown out of the window. It isn't funny, it's actually very dark. Considering that I thought of it as more of a low comedy because even if you didn't understand the underlying ideas you would still think it was funny after reading it.
  • I understood the ideas of consumerism and materialism in the play and that they were becoming a part of the The American Dream. I completely missed other things though in the book, for example the implication that Daddy had a sex change. I understood the role reversals in the play from the beginning but I hadn't realized the true extent till discussing it in class. This shows how matriculated he is and is supposed to add to the meaning of exchanged between Mommy and Daddy.