Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading: If It Happened There . . . the Government Shutdown by Joshua Keating


In If It Happened There . . . the Government Shutdown, Joshua Keating discusses the then potential government shutdown similar to how American media would report on it in other countries. The essay looks at the different players in the shutdown: President Barack Obama, the Democratic Party, John Bohner, the Republican Party, and the Tea Party. Whenever an essay is written about anything, especially politics it is impossible to write it objectively. A reader’s response to it is also far from objective it is heavily based on their own views. Regardless of personal views, Keating uses diction, details, and imagery well to create a satiric essay that shows the hypocrisy and ridiculousness of the American government and the media.  
Keating’s word choice creates a sarcastic tone that shows the sharp contrast in the manner the media reports the news whether domestic or foreign. He also shows that the disagreement in D.C. is childish.  He refers to the different political parties as “rival clans”, this makes it seem like this whole problem of the government the shutdown is almost a game. “Rival clans” brings to mind what two opposing groups would be called in a video game. This may not seem significant but combined with the other word choices it helps create the tone and meaning. Keating then refers to Obama and to the executive branch as a “regime”, he could have easily referred to it as the executive branch. However that would not contributed to creating the tone and meaning. The word “regime” is used throughout the essay and it is associated with authoritarian forms of government and that is interpreted negatively in the U.S.   The word is used often by the media when reporting on the governments of foreign nations. The word choice shows how a person’s perspective on an issue needs to be taken into consideration. Referring to the different parties as “rival clans” gives the reader the idea that the whole shutdown is as childish as a game. The use of the word regime shows the difference in the way the media reports on different issues. The overall word choices by Keating help create the meaning of the essay.

Keating adds details that help convey the meaning behind the essay. In the third paragraph he mentions that one of the main causes the recent shutdown would be Obama care. This seems legitimate and does not seem to have much deeper meaning behind it but he then adds to the sentence, “to bring the nation’s health care system in line with international standards”. This now gives the reader the idea that what the fighting is over is absurd, in that Obama’s opposition does not have a legitimate argument. This furthers the idea that the fighting in D.C. is childish. Later in the article in the fifth paragraph, Keating describes what Ted Cruz did but it is not simply factual. He adds his thoughts on the situation by describing what Cruz did: “quoting liberally from the science fiction films and children’s books”. This gives the reader the idea that the whole deal with Cruz was childish and frankly pointless. Keating does not come out and directly say this but he is able to convey this through his use of details. Then one the reader considers how these two examples would be conveyed by the media if it had been taking place in another country helps further Keating’s main meaning. He uses details to show that the whole situation with the government shutdown and what lead up to it was immature and then continues to show the difference in the media’s perspectives.

Keating does not use a lot of imagery but the little that he does use is effective in creating a picture in the reader’s mind. In the introduction, Keating mentions that the then looming government shutdown was not apparent in D.C. He then goes on to say that, “Beret-wearing colonels have not yet taken to the airwaves to declare martial law”. The reader can picture this in their mind, but it is not a fear of the American people. This idea seems very far fetched to Americans but it would be how it is reported if a similar situation was taking place in another country. The idea would not seem far fetched for the image Keating described to take place in another country. This shows the difference in the way the media reports news and how it is interpreted. Keating uses imagery again in the last paragraph, “while driving down the poorly maintained roads that lead from the airport, “Do these guys have any idea what they’re  doing to the country?” This is a question that is asked by Keating’s cab driver. At this point the tone of the essay shifts a bit, it becomes more serious as he presents the reader the question whether the people in D.C. really know anything. The reader can picture themselves in the cab with Keating as driver mentions this.  This helps present the question to the reader and make the reader think about the message Keating is trying to convey throughout his essay. This is true for all the details he includes.

Keating uses diction, details, and imagery to convey his message that the then probable (now a reality) shutdown that was a result of disagreements is ridiculous and that the way the media portrays domestic issues differs from how they portray foreign issues. A case can be made for Keating being on Obama’s side and even on the Republican’s side. It depends on how you interpret the essay but his message does not change.




I had a lot of mixed reactions to the essay. When I first read it was really amusing and interesting, after looking more closely at it more closely it became clear that Keating was frustrated with the government and media. As I kept rereading it I would notice more of the little details that I might have missed the previous time I read it. I then thought of the personal bias that he must have when writing this essay and that that I also have in reading and responding to it. No matter your reaction the essay, it definitely makes you think about what is happening with the government and how the media portrays it. 


4 comments:

  1. Hi Susheela,
    I miss having classes with you this year! I always enjoyed hearing your opinions on topics covered in class, as well as national issues. However, for now, I guess I just have to settle for reviewing your blog posts:) Your ability to pick up on the author's sarcasm and mockery of the high officials in government shows you are a mature reader. "Rivaling clans" reminds me of somewhat barbaric people fighting for one purpose--. Your statement that the use of the phrase compared the behavior of government officials to if they were competing in a “childish [video] game,” was the kind of emotion the author was trying to evoke. The Executive Branch as a "regime" is another great example of the author using diction to prove their point. The author clearly is not a supporter of Republicans in Congress, nor are they speaking highly of the President. Personally, I think the author did a good job in not being bias in his critique of the government shutdown. You mentioned that the author was detailed in their descriptions of what had been taking place in Congress. Instead of the author plainly stating that Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) made a speech, they made sure to be more descriptive by mentioning the actual content of his infamous 21-hour speech. Throughout the whole article you mentioned how Obama’s time in office is likened to a king’s rule in a monarchy. To balance out any bias, the author likens Obama to an king, which is not seen as positive in the U.S. Overall, I think you analyzed this article perfectly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Audrey! I do miss hearing your opinions in APUSH, but thankfully I get to read them here again! You have a wonderful and captivating voice when you write, similar to your actual presence, which is a wonderful trait for a writer. It's amusing to me that both you, me and Davis chose articles about the government shutdown, but I guess that shows just how much it was on everyone's mind. Though I enjoyed this close reading, a few parts were a bit vague. For example in your first paragraph you say that "[w]henever an essay is written about anything...," which is quite general writing (and also it's a bit passive!). Another thing to keep in mind when writing these is that you need to maintain sentence variation. The majority of your paragraphs start off with "Keating." This is repetitive and not pleasing to read. Besides those little issues, I think this essay is really great and your voice makes it entertaining to read!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Adding to what everyone had said, i did enjoy reading this post and hearing your opinions on this topic. Providing support and what your opinions are on what author wrote throughout the article was done excellently. Especially , when you were describing how the author of the article was referring the political parties as "Rival clans" being more a childish game, letting the readers know that there might be more to it, because of the word choices the author had specifically used to help the authors views and you do a great job of that.
    Agreeing with Sierra i did notice that you had started a lot of sentences with "Keating" just fixing that and adding sentence variation would be nice.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Susheela--excellent analysis! It's well-organized and well-supported.

    ReplyDelete