Sunday, February 16, 2014

Response to Course Material 2/16

We’ve done a lot in the last couple of weeks, we wrote our summary and analysis for Hamlet, we learned what not to do in our open prompts, and read Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead.

We wrote our second open prompt and learned from Ms. Holmes that they needed work. The introduction in my first open prompt was ok, but I don’t know why I made the grave mistake of diverting from what we were told to do with my second introduction. That’s something that I will definitely change. I’m trying to get used to the idea that my whole introduction can be a thesis paragraph and that I don’t have to try and force everything into one sentence. This is different from the majority of essays that I’ve written in the past from Brit Lit to APUSH where you had to have a one sentence thesis. In my second open prompt my introduction was in this format instead of the one we should use for AP Lit. The in class work we did with introductions definitely helped a lot. It was kind of funny that the introduction that Ms. Holmes wanted us to write was actually easier because it had a clear format, than the ones where we pretty much winged it (at least for me).

Then we read Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead, I really like this play. It was fun to read in class, but I like it more now that we’ve started discussing it. The movie is interesting especially because Stoppard directed it himself, I found myself accidently confusing what happened in the movie with what actually happened in the play. Ms. Holmes told our class to treat the play as we would an essay/handout we would receive in class because this is how Stoppard wants use to interpret the play, but that doesn’t mean it’s the right interpretation. We haven’t answered all the questions about the play that were presented in class, but we decided that we are all on a boat. I think we’ll be able to answer the other questions once we do our close reading. The dynamic between Rosencrantz and Guildenstern is similar to the one Lenny and George has in Of Mice and Men, it reminded me of the novel we read sophomore year. We also received a handout on the play about a lecture and why the play is Theater of the Absurd. I disagree with this and I think it is more existential because if the play was Theater of the Absurd that means that it has no meaning. I think the play does have meaning, my class hasn’t reached a final decision on what exactly that is, and the idea that the play is meaningless is something we all disagreed with. We thought it had to do with whether we all have free will and how Stoppard seems to be trying to point that out by pointing out that we’re not in a play. We’ll probably decide on a meaning after we do our close reading.

3 comments:

  1. Susheela,
    I can totally relate to you on the intro practice/work. As you mentioned, I'm so used to being told, "the thesis has to be in one sentence blah blah blah." My brain is wired to do that, so it's difficult to try to separate it now, which is kind of ironic! One thing I think you might want to include regarding intros is our in class practices. How did you feel about the time constraint when we had to write our own prompts, and then answer two? For me, it was super difficult and stressful more than anything. One thing you do a great job of in your response is relating our material to other classes/outside things. I really liked your connection between Of Mice and Men and Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. I never would have thought of it, but you got me thinking now! Overall, good work on your post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Susheela,

    You did connect what we’ve done in AP lit to experiences you’ve had in other classes, but I think you could breathe a bit more life into your paper if you were to relate our activities to things you do outside of school. Just a thought. Anyways, I don’t remember Ms. Holmes telling us to interpret Stoppard’s play in the way we do the handouts that accompany the works (though I could have just been gone for band festival or something). The only reason I say that is because that seems like it would restrict our understanding of the play to only one lens. I personally believe that literature is a form of art, and all art should be able to be freely interpreted by the viewer. With the discussion of literary lenses we did this last week, it may be fun to look back on your analysis of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead and think about other ways you could have interpreted the play.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Susheela,
    I love how you started this by noting the things we’ve done so that as a reader I knew what I was about to read. You did a really good job of relating to things outside of AP Lit. I’m right there with you on intros and the format being different than how we’ve done it in Brit Lit of APUSH. Oddly enough having to write them the way Ms. Holmes would like is harder for me, I think I use those “fluffy” and cheesy introduction sentences to get my thoughts formed and flowing, somehow I need to figure out how to break this habit. I like how you compared Rosencrantz and Guildenstern’s relationship to that of Lenny and George. I hadn’t thought of that before but I can completely see it (I know I had compared their relationship to that of two brothers with a significant age gap with Rosencrantz being the younger and trying to impress his older brother). I also think it’s interesting that you feel there is a meaning to the play. Personally I don’t think there is one. While I feel Stoppard was commenting on a few things I don’t think it was significant enough to amount to a meaning. I would love to know what your class decided the meaning was. Great job Susheela!

    ReplyDelete