Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt 2 (2/9/14)

2004. Critic Roland Barthes has said, “Literature is the question minus the answer.” Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes’ observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author’s treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.

                In William Shakespeare’s Hamlet the central question that appears is who Hamlet will decide he will be. The situation he is placed in at Elsinore creates an identity crisis that is resolved to some extent near the end of the play. The two versions of him that can be seen the Hamlet that swears to kill Claudius because  his earthly father’s ghost asks him  and the other version of him that has morals and wants to return to Wittenberg, whom he himself desire to be. Shakespeare answers the central question be creating a compromise between the two versions of Hamlet: one who is loyal to his father and regains his morals. Shakespeare uses this question and answer to show the reader the deeper issues plaguing Elsinore and how it is the root cause of the problems in the play.
                Through out the play Hamlet is conflicted within himself of his own identity and this is what causes the question to arise of whom he will be. Hamlet is caught between duty and desire. His duty is to Denmark as their future ruler and to his father, Old Hamlet and former King, and his family. His desire is to return to Wittenberg and continue to be a scholar. This version of Hamlet is coupled with his morality and his views on God. His inner conflict with identity is magnified when he is asked by his father’s ghost to avenge his death. Hamlet is caught between his loyalty to his father and his own morality. Hamlet is forced to decide who he is because of the situation he is in.
                Who Hamlet decides he is, is the answer to the central question. There is no one simple answer to this question and Shakespeare leaves room for the reader to form their own version of him. Regardless it is very hard to say that he is simply one of the two versions mentioned previously and not a combination of the two. One who is loyal to his father, but also regains his morality. He does kill Claudius, his uncle who murdered his father, and avenges his death. However he still has his morality and his faith in God. When he does kill Claudius it was not planned and it was after the “fall of the sparrow” speech in which he regains his faith and puts it in God. After it the reader is given the idea that his identity conflict is resolved, and that he will maintain his morality. Then he is put in a situation in which he can kill Claudius, be loyal to his father, and maintain his morals. This is who Hamlet decides he will be, he finds compromise between the two versions of him.
                Shakespeare’s treatment of the central question and answer affect the reader’s understanding of the play deeply. He leaves some room for the reader to come to their own conclusion of the play and who Hamlet really is. Readers believe they know who he is when he promises the ghost that he will avenge him and is instrumental in bringing about his friends’ Rosencrantz and Guildenstern’s death. Then the reader is given the other version of Hamlet, after his “fall of the sparrow” speech. At these key moments in the play it seems that the central question is answered, but it is not because of events that occur after that challenge his identity. Shakespeare uses this to build up to the moment where Gertrude, Laertes, Claudius, and Hamlet all die in one scene.  All of these moments in the play highlight the inner issues in Denmark and specifically Elsinore to the reader.
                Who Hamlet decides he will be is the central question in the play Hamlet. The question is posed early on in the play between the Hamlet who is loyal to his father versus the moral one who desires to be a scholar and return to Wittenberg. The medium that is reached between the two is the answer to the question. Shakespeare uses this to show to the reader the much deeper issues in Elsinore and “how something is rotten in Denmark”.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Susheela,
    Great work on this prompt! I had the same question, which I'm starting to think wasn't coincidental... anyways, you pretty much nailed it. The only critique I have is in your intro. (No worries, I know this was before our intro practice.) Although you did address what the question was in Hamlet, you didn't really address how it contributes to the overall meaning of the work, and to what extent. If you add these elements into your thesis this essay would be terrific! I really liked the claims you made, particularly, the idea of duty v desire. I didn't really think about using this, but you presented and argued it well. Overall, just focus on your intro and you should be good to go. Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Susheela,

    Alongside Alex, I definitely think the biggest problem here is your introduction paragraph. I mean, you’re mainly just restating the prompt question and then following it up with a thesis. Speaking of your thesis, it looks disturbingly similar to Caitlin’s, so I’m going to comment along the same lines I did to her. The manner in which you wrote your thesis makes it seem as though the question isn’t getting through since you’re saying Shakespeare is posing the puzzling question of who is Hamlet to his audiences, and quite frankly the way the question is worded limits it within only the bounds of Shakespeare’s world of Hamlet (plus, now that I think about it, doesn’t Hamlet decide who he is at the end with his whole “fall of the sparrow” speech; yeah, there’s the answer). I believe that Barthes is discussing literature that asks questions about our society or morals and never gives a response as to the best path. Please excuse my extremely poor example, but it would be like a novel that poses the question, “is slavery wrong,” yet never definitively says/shows whether it is or isn’t. Though, I would hope that particular question never goes unanswered in any work of literature…

    ReplyDelete
  3. Susheela,
    This was a pretty solid essay. Having written about the same central question this was definitely an interesting essay for me to read. I like how you went about the duty vs. desire angle and also used his fall of the sparrow speech and reaffirmation in God to show his deciding of his identity. Having looked at it from a completely different angle (his identity coming with deciding who really was his father) I thought you arguments were strong and liked how you pointed out that his murder of Claudius was not premeditated and came after giving up control to God. It seems we both need to work on our intro paragraphs, I’m sensing a little fluff in both and a little bit of the prompt missing (how it affects the overall meaning of the work). Having reviewed your last open prompt essay, I can say there is a definite improvement and at this rate you’ll be fine by the time of AP testing. Great work Susheela!

    ReplyDelete