Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading: Inside the Box (12/8/13)

In the article Inside the Box Jessica Olien draws attention to how society adamantly claims that it loves creativity, but constantly shuns it. She explains how it is commonly unaccepted providing examples as evidence for her assertions. Then goes on to emphasize how it is under attack by society in numerous ways. Olien uses diction, syntax, and details to show how creativity is constantly praised, but in reality it is under attack by society.

Olien uses diction well to further her argument. In the first paragraph she refers to creativity as a “virtue” and a trait that is “celebrated”. This helps set a positive tone for the first paragraph because the word “virtue” and “celebrated” have good and happy connotations. These two words also give the reader the idea that creativity is very important. Later in the seventh paragraph Olien gives references the documentary The September Issue (about Vogue magazine), and she points out that the many ideas of the creative director are “reject(ed)” by Anna Wintour (editor-in-cheief). Olien does not simply say that the ideas are simply “reject(ed)”, but “systematically reject(ed)”. This is an important difference because of what the word “systematically” implies to the reader: that creativity is constantly denied and that this single example is universal. Olien’s word choice helps her convey her message to the reader.

While the tone of the first paragraph was positive, it came to a screeching halt in the second paragraph with one simple little sentence, “It’s all a lie”. The sentence is emphasized because of how short it is, especially compared to the rest of Olien’s sentences. It draws emphasis to the main idea of her article: that society claims to love creativity, but truly hate it. The sentence comes after what was discussed about diction in the first paragraph, so it also contrasts with that, and the short sentence emphasizes it because of how abrupt it is. She also uses hyphens to draw emphasis to other parts of the article. In the eleventh paragraph Olien highlights a “place where our first creative ideas go to die is the place that should be most open to them-schools”. The hyphen adds emphasis to the idea that schools hurt creativity, even though it is a long sentence. Olien utilizes syntax well to change the tone and add emphasis. All of this is to show how creativity is not widely valued and accepted, even though people think it is.

The details included in the article help Olien make her case. She includes a quote from Dave Hickey: “Everybody hates it when something’s really great”. This detail is significant because it reinforces the idea that creativity is great and that it is not accepted at once. The quote (in context) also implies that the reason behind creativity being rejected is people do not like success of others. This is a very negative concept and is used by Olien to strengthen her argument that creativity is rejected for terrible reasons. Then she shows the value of creativity by including the detail how “adults’ accomplishments are linked far more strongly to their creativity than their IQ” in the twelfth paragraph. The detail comes in the paragraph that continues to discus schools and as a result the detail implies that creativity should be fostered at school and should be more important than education. The details included in the article are used by Olien to stress the importance of creativity and draw attention to why it is often rejected.


Diction, syntax, and details are used well by Olien to show creativity is not accepted even though it is important and should be. She uses them to explain to the reader while people claim to value creativity it, it is not valued. Then goes on to say that for creativity to succeed one must be determined and not give up on it.  

4 comments:

  1. http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2013/12/creativity_is_rejected_teachers_and_bosses_don_t_value_out_of_the_box_thinking.html
    Here's the link to the article, I forgot to put it in the original post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Susheela,
    Overall I think this was a pretty good post and I liked the article you chose. I thought your thesis was good and you did a good job showing how diction, syntax, and details highlighted your thesis. In your diction paragraph you said “the word ‘systematically’ implies to the reader: that creativity is constantly denied”. When reading through the article I personally did not think that “systematically” was implying that creativity was constantly denied, but consciously denied, that there was thought put into the decision and that it didn’t happen every time. Both could be right, I would just be careful when you say that something is implied. I thought you syntax paragraph was great and your examples were perfect for illustrating your point. Your detail paragraph was also good and I enjoyed your discussion of how the details impacted the article. This was a really good post; the only thing I would say is maybe add in a few more textual examples, especially in the detail and syntax paragraphs. Great job Susheela.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Susheela,
    I liked your example of "systematically rejected" and I think it does mean those things are automatically disposed of. I disagree with what Caitlin said, that it meant it was thoughtfully removed. However I will say that your first couple of diction examples were really weak. "Virtue" and "celebrated." I don't know. They just don't seem like particular diction selections to me. But "Systematic" is definitely a good example.

    On the other hand, I love the examples you chose for syntax. They're all great, but you credited the hyphen with emphasizing schools' destruction of creative thought. Does the hyphen really do all that? I think the author should have used a colon. That would have worked better there and done what you're describing (and what I believe the author is attempting to achieve), which is isolating the word "schools" for greater emphasis, and a kind of unveiling effect.

    I love the detail about creativity being a greater sign of success than IQ. I believe it, too. I think you're right about that detail showing how ironic it is that school preps us for success but tends to purely focus on measurable intelligence like our MEAP tests or ACT/SAT or IQ.

    What a cool article! Good job with dissecting it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Susheela,
    Great article choice, I wholeheartedly agree with the author's view of creativity in our modern world. Your first paragraph served as a thoughtful introduction to your essay and included a solid thesis statement. My one qualm, though, was your beginning a sentence with the word then-- "She explains how it is commonly unaccepted providing examples as evidence for her assertions. Then goes on to emphasize how it is under attack by society in numerous ways." Perhaps it was a mistake, but the second sentence is a bit of a fragment; the two would be better connected with a comma, or rewritten with a semi-colon. Just a suggestion, though! Your body paragraphs had plenty of good evidence from the text and did well to emphasize your arguments regarding the article. I also commend you for including a concluding paragraph to the post. That’s something I tend to neglect to do, and must work on in future blogs. Wonderful post Susheela!

    ReplyDelete