The 2004 open prompt was: Critic Roland Barthes has said, “Literature is the question minus the answer.” Choose a novel, or play, and, considering Barthes’ observation, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author’s treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.
Student N:
Essay N is the best of the three essays without a doubt. The author starts the essay by addressing the question right away in the introduction. He/she chose to use Candide for the essay. They had a thesis and stuck with it. They use evidence to support the claims made and do a good job of tying everything back to the question. The student explains the plot of the novel but does so without summarizing. The organization was fairly simple and easy to follow. The essay did become a bit repetitive when he/she was discussing the phrase “tending our garden”. There are some grammatical errors that take away from the essay. The only other problems with the essay are that the lack of sophistication in the use of language and the syntax as mentioned previously has some mistakes. The author has a clear conclusion that ties back to his introduction. The essay successfully answers the prompt and that is the number one objective.
Student J:
The author of Essay J choose the very well known novel Adventures of Huckleberry Fin. The essay contained much more summarization than analysis. In the first paragraph, the introduction, the author has a clear thesis that addresses the prompt. The second paragraph is mostly a summary of the book, it provides very little analysis. The third paragraph focuses more on the question, the first sentence in it goes back to the main question. The author unnecessarily goes into discussing what their issues with society, even though it addresses the complexities of the book. This would have been fine if the author had connected it back with the main focus of the essay. They would have then strengthened the essay. The fourth paragraph discusses whether Huck and Jim were actually successful. It addresses the complexities of the issues they are dealing with, “Jim is still restricted by the conventions of modern society’s discrimination against blacks and Huck is restricted by the conventions of modern society, clothes and manners, against which he chafes”. The sentence though sounds redundant. The essay would be much stronger if the author had tied back this paragraph with the main point of the essay. The conclusion tires to tie everything together again. Overall the author barely answers the question without much deep analysis.
Student U:
Essay U tries to answer the prompt by focusing on the novel Things Fall Apart. It received the lowest score of the three essays because it did not truly answer the prompt and mostly gave a summary of the novel. The essay consists of two paragraphs, this would not be that much of an issue if the ideas were well developed and supported but they are not. The structure does not help either. The first paragraph, the introduction, is spent on discussing the conflicts in the essay. The author develops a great question: “…does anything ever stay the same?” In the second paragraph of the essay, the author continues to discuss the conflicts within the novel, near the end of the paragraph the author tries to tie everything back to the question. In a way the author answers the prompt but it is nowhere near sufficient. There is a significant lack of analysis in the essay. There are no examples to support the essay, just claims that are poorly explained. Their main idea of the essay was a good one (the question), if the author had been able to expand on it and support it with examples the essay could have been great. Overall though the essay does not answer the prompt.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHola Susheela,
ReplyDeleteLet me start by saying I have been really enjoying the color scheme of your blog as I write these comments--purple rules. Anyway, I see here that you ACTUALLY did the open prompt assignment while many of us not-as-capable students accidentally critiqued closed prompts (oh, well:). You were able to make note of why you think each student received their score, and noticed the strengths and weakness of each essay. However, you do a lot of paraphrasing here. I think using more quotes from each essay (at least one) that displays an author's complete thought is very helpful in these posts; it just adds more to your case when you are agreeing or refuting with something the author said. Another suggestion I have is to include the scores that each student received. As students approaching their fate on the AP English Literature test, it is great to see examples of students’ essays and having their score available too.
I liked that you pointed out the reasons why the essay got there points, showing the strength's and weaknesses of each student like what audrey had pointed out. but i think i could add what your thoughts on the essays as well, did you agree with the AP scorer or not? what did you learn not to do? what did you get from reaching these essays?
ReplyDeleteWow! You follow directions better than ninety percent of AP Lit. Students and actually did an Open Prompt analysis -- kudos! I find it extremely helpful that you included the prompt at the beginning of your analyses to help the reader better understand what you're talking about; I'm going to have to start doing that! Though I'm unsure as to whether they show the scores of the students' essays in an actual Open Prompt (because I've yet to do one of those), I'm guessing by the way you included the score for the third student that they do. Like Audrey said, it would be helpful if you could mention the scores of all three students' essays. I love the way you write your analysis, they're very inviting to read, for example I liked that you said that is "the number one objective," referring to actually answering the prompt! Side note: I can't believe that student number three only wrote two paragraphs! That scares me that he/she panicked and probably ran out of time -- I don't want that to happen to me! Overall, this is an excellent analysis, Susheela!
ReplyDelete