Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt 9/22/13

In the 2005 AP exam the open prompt asked students to compare and contrast two poems by William Blake both titled “The Chimney Sweeper”. They needed to be able to discuss the different techniques used in each poem and their meaning.


Student Response #1:
The essay achieves its objectives of discussing the different uses of language and meaning even though it lacks a conclusion. The first paragraph introduces the main idea of the essay and explains the similarities and differences of the two works. It addresses the structural similarities of the two poems and difference in their tone. The second paragraph focuses on the similarities in style, rhyme scheme, and points out that Blake shows, “he has working class sensibilities” in both poems. The third paragraph centers on the differences of the two poems, from the tone to the explicitness of Blake’s message. The essay uses examples clearly to support main ideas. There is also a clear logical organization of ideas that allows a reader to understand the arguments made easily. The ideas are tied together well and work together to answer the prompt. The essay doesn’t have a conclusion that would help wrap up the essay and a clear thesis even though it meets the objectives of the open prompt. Also with and ‘and’ are not fully written out in the essay, instead the student uses w/ and &. Overall the essay is able to achieve its main goal.


Student Response #2:
The essay doesn’t fully achieve the main objectives. There are strong parts in the essay, were arguments are made well and elaborated on with examples. However in other places the student does not thoroughly discuss and defend the assertions made. The introduction discusses the use of poetry as a whole, as a means of change and introduces the different poetic techniques used in both poems. The introduction is choppy in making this jump.  The second paragraph focuses on the diction used and successfully discusses Blake’s use of dark/light and black/white as a metaphor to express the “innocence” of the children and their “death”. The third paragraph poorly discuses syntax and the rhyme scheme. The discussion of syntax is under covered and the claim is not supported well. The main focus of the third paragraph is how, “God is shown to have a different relationship to the young chimney sweeps”. This paragraph is a well-constructed, it has examples that are clearly explained. The fourth paragraph is the conclusion, the student tries to tie all the ideas presented in the essay together. However it yet again makes too big of a leap trying to expand into the effect these poems had on society in the past and how people today need to see the important “activism” in poetry. This conclusion does not strengthen the essay. Overall the essay focuses on the main objectives but there are parts that need clear improvement.   

Student Response #3:
This essay does not achieve the main objectives, it focuses on one thing: the role of God in each poem. The introduction discusses the difference in tone but the scoring commentary points out that this is an example of the student not understanding the use of irony. The second and third paragraph could be one paragraph because they both focus on the role of God in both poems. The second discusses how in one poem it leads to inspiring the boy.  While in the third paragraph it mentions how the role of God, “highlight[s] the hypocrisy of the boy’s parent’s actions”.  This is the only idea discussed thoroughly and it would help the student to of made it one whole paragraph. Breaking it into two doesn’t help and they seem redundant. The fourth paragraph (that is the conclusion) tries to tie all the ideas together but only the role of God was really discussed. Overall the essay does not answer the question, because it does not discuss any techniques.

2 comments:

  1. Susheela,
    For the open prompt blog post assignment you were supposed to choose a prompt in which the student selected the literature to analyze. This question involved the prompts already having been chosen.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Susheela,

    I think you did the same thing that Rachel did...and now I'm not sure if Mariah and I did the right thing or you and Rachel did the right thing...I believe we were supposed to pick and essay that GIVES THE STUDENT A PROMPT and uses literature they know to answer and answer the prompt and support their thesis. But I'll comment as much as I can anyway. I liked your analysis of the students' essays. It made me feel that you knew what to look for in a well constructed essay. You were very specific on why or why the essay wasn't good (for example: spelling, explanations, incorrect use of vocabulary etc.) and it helped me understand what readers are looking for. You were reading closely for specific use of technique in the essays and you answered those nicely in each essay. Nice job....hopefully you get credit for this! (Assuming that Mariah and I did the right thing)

    ReplyDelete