Sunday, September 15, 2013

Close Reading: A Win-Win-Win for Everyone (Except the Syrians) by Fred Kaplan


In A Win-Win-Win for Everyone (Except the Syrians), Fred Kaplan discusses the resolution reached over the use of chemical weapons in the civil war in Syria. It is a comprehensive article that discusses the positions of Barack Obama, the United States’s Congress, Vladimir Putin, Bashar al-Assad, and the Syrians. The diction, syntax, and details used by Kaplan helps convey his biases views that everyone except the Syrians in a sense won whether it is Putin who won because of clever plotting and Obama who won because of sheer luck.

Kaplan uses formal diction throughout the article, there are numerous examples of this. The first example is in the fifth paragraph where he uses the word “gambit” describing Putin’s proposal that was criticized by some Americans. He could've used the word proposal, or tactic. However this word adds to creating an image of Putin as being clever and scheming; the one that set things into motion. This also aids him in portraying Obama as weak and cornered.  In the eighth paragraph Kaplan says “[Putin] took the narrowest slice of Obama’s rhetoric”, narrowest slice adds to the meaning. It gives the reader the impression that Putin found a loophole to get out of this whole mess. If Kaplan used a different phrase such as ‘part’ the reader would not be given that impression. Kaplan uses diction cleverly to portray Putin and Obama a certain way to convey his message. In the tenth paragraph, Kaplan says that Obama will get “at least joint credit” for the agreement. Kaplan did not need to use “at least”, he would have been fine leaving that out and just saying “joint credit”. However this would of given the reader a different impression. “[A]t least” makes it seem  that Obama got lucky with in the end and that he really did not have any real part in the result. Kaplan’s diction in this article paints Putin as the one who made the crucial decisions and now Obama is lucky with the results.

Kaplan also uses syntax to his advantage to deliver his message clearly. He uses sentence fragments to add emphasis and add the slight sense of confusion. In the eighth paragraph the last sentence is “End of story”. It adds emphasis and abruptly ends the trail of thought. This leaves the reader with the idea that Putin’s one move is what changed everything even though John Kerry and Sergey Lavrov were both discussing Syria. It is possible that Putin made the call but there is no way of knowing that for sure but the use of the sentence fragment leaves the reader with that impression. He uses a sentence fragment again to start the last paragraph, “And who knows?”. This emphasizes the ideas that are about to come and gives a sense of momentary confusion and unknown possibilities. That is what Kaplan says is possible because of this resolution. If that did not start the sentence the same idea would be portrayed but not as efficiently. The confusion brought on helps create the sense of unknown that Kaplan is trying to achieve.

The details that were in the article are important to notice. They help Kaplan send his message. He gives background information in the second and third paragraph on why Putin had very good motivation to have the chemical weapons removed. The information is crucial in creating the idea that Putin had more incentive to begin with than Obama to remove the chemical weapons. That Putin did not want or like the “chaos” that was created by Assad’s use of chemical weapons. This idea does have some merit however the image it paints does not. It make is seem that Putin has more motivation and that is where the idea of him having more power and control of the situation also begin. Then in the twelfth paragraph Kaplan mentions the “Chapter VII resolution—that is, a resolution that includes enforcement through the use of force.”. This detail adds to what the reader views Putin has been able to achieve. It makes it so that there are consequences for the Syrians not complying. It helps portray Putin as more powerful and of having been the one to bring about the resolution.
Kaplan uses diction, syntax, and details to give the reader the impression that the resolution was courtesy of Putin and Obama is lucky that it took place. It is biased in that sense, the article is not objective, it portrays Obama achieving his goal as just luck and not a result of his threats to strike Syria. This is seen through the analysis of the article.

2 comments:

  1. Susheela,
    After reading the article, I shared many of your opinions. Your view on Kaplan’s diction is very accurate. Putin was described very negatively. He came off as a power hungry, controlling ruler. While I am not entirely informed on this situation, I know that leaders are portrayed in every light. Kaplan is definitely using his powerful verbs and adjectives for such a reason. Your evidence was spread out throughout the article which gave it strength and tied your paragraph together. I don’t think your topic sentence is the most fitting, since you emphasize on how his diction is portrayed rather than it being formal. I struggle identifying syntax, but your evidence and details made it very clear. The short sentences did add emphasis and once again you address the article as a whole; not straying away from the big picture. Lastly, the details you use help your argument about how Obama and Putin are described. Putin is addressed much more frequently in the article, and those details shaped how he was perceived through the reading. Overall, this is a great close read; you keep the big picture in sight while bringing up substantial evidence to prove your point.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Susheela,

    This is my last post, so please don't blame me for making mistakes here. I'm so excited that I'm going to be finished soon! Ok now on to your post. First of all, I'd like to question your use of 'formal diction' in your post. I saw extremely well developed examples of the use of specified diction to portray the tone but not quite 'formal' diction. You were dead on about the syntax. Your examples made it clear to me the confusion and emphasis of the piece. I got a little confused in the last paragraph about details. I see your point when they use specific examples and the background story, and those are certainly details. However, I didn't quite get the argument of why it was important to the piece. Seeing that I haven't read the article yet, I would have liked to see more explanation in that section. Overall, nice job with the annotation. You really took your time to look at all the small details and your understanding can be shown well through this post.

    ReplyDelete