Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt 2 (3/9/14)


2006. Many writers use a country setting to establish values within a work of literature. For example, the country may be a place of virtue and peace or one of primitivism and ignorance. Choose a novel or play in which such a setting plays a significant role. Then write an essay in which you analyze how the country setting functions in the work as a whole.
*This is the prompt I've been trying to avoid like the plague, but here goes:

            In Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman Miller uses the country side to show Will Loman’s longing to live in the past. Willy at his age is trying to resurrect a time where he had more hope in himself and for his family. He has flashbacks and he considers this to have been a better time. The country is used by Miller to show Willy’s inability to let go of the past combined with his unrealistic expectations lead to his eventual downfall.
            While the country setting is not the main setting in the play, it is used by Miller to show that Willy is living in the past. Willy constantly hears his father’s flute play, similar to when he was a child and they lived in the country. He is filled with nostalgia when he thinks of this and believes this to have been a better time than the present. Willy also has flashbacks about his older brother Ben, who made his fortune in the jungle that is in a sense the country. Those flashbacks show Willy’s regret of not doing the same. In one he tells Linda that he is going to go with Ben and Linda tells him not to because he is doing fine. Willy is consumed with nostalgia and regret and the country side is used to show that.
Willy has unrealistic hopes and dreams concerning himself and his family. Willy is out of touch with reality and he sees himself “as a prince among men” and not a dime a dozen what he truly is. His dreams are symbolized by the seeds that represent his children and have a strong connection to the country. The seeds Willy plants never grow similar to how his children never reach the potential he believes they have. However he does not acknowledge this when asked about his oldest, Biff, he replies that he is doing “big things”. When the seeds fail to grow Willy’s solution is to move to the country, he believes that all of his and his family’s problems can be solved simply by that. This is highly unrealistic that move will not solve anything. Willy believes that their problems are not real and this can be a solution.
Willy in the end of the play commits suicide because he lives in the past and has a flexible relationship with reality. The country side contributes to his death because of that. He kills himself believing that the insurance money his family will receive from his death will allow for the success of his children. This is another unrealistic expectation. He also constantly believes that the past was better and that the current situation is not enough. Throughout the play the country shows just that. He was also talking to Ben a while before he committed suicide, another connection to the country, and is contemplating the effects of suicide.
Miller uses the country setting in Death of a Salesman to show how Willy lives in the past and believes that it would be the answer to everything. He is filled with false hope and this is also conveyed by Miller’s use of the country. Both of these things together lead to Willy’s suicide.   

             

3 comments:

  1. in your first paragraph be sure to use only one tense. You have present and past and its a little confusing. (he had, he has). When you say, "inability to let go of the past" is it bad that I immediately thought of Frozen? Okay, sorry, I got a little sidetracked. Anyway, umm isn't the setting in this play in Brooklyn New York? In your third paragraph when you say, "He kills himself believing that the insurance money his family will receive from his death will allow for the success of his children. This is another unrealistic expectation." What does this have to do with the country setting? It fits the category of unrealistic expectations, but does not answer the prompt? I don't know, maybe the question confused me, but I don't really understand how some things can relate to the country.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Susheela,
    Well I completely understand why you were trying to avoid this prompt like the plague. This one is super tricky, especially considering we have only read works this year that are based in big cities. Taking the difficulty of this prompt into mind I do have some critics. First I would suggest adding a meaning statement about the work at the end of your first paragraph because even when the prompt doesn't require it, it is helpful to make your paragraph topics based off of it to further provide evidence for the point you are trying to make with the essay. As far as actual content, I would suggest brainstorming a little more before writing the essay because it isn't exactly clear the points you are trying to make in each paragraph. The discussion of the countryside representing Willy needs a little more evidence considering they didn't talk much about the countryside at all in the play. Either way, I realize this is a hard prompt and good attempt!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Susheela,
    You do a nice job with your opening sentence getting right to the point, as this type of essay requires. However, some of your claim seem unsupported, and there seems to be kind of a disconnect between your ideas about the setting and your ideas about meaning. I may be wrong, but I don't recall hearing that Willy grew up in the country, and he never flashes back to his childhood. His flashbacks to happier times were when his kinds were younger and full of potential. If you can find more support that Willy did grow up in a country setting, you should include it in your essay. My suggestion would be to have a paragraph just on the country setting and it's role in the plot, and then have a separate paragraph or two tying it to meaning. Your argument would be clearer and more supported. Regarding the disconnect between your ideas on the country setting and the meaning, I think you just need more evidence and explanations. It looks like you wrote an idea in the meaning, and then say it's related to the country setting without explaining how or why. But don't get discouraged, you have some good thoughts on meaning in here. This is a very tough prompt and these essays are pretty difficult. I avoided responding to a response to this prompt in part one for the very reason that I didn't want to respond to it in part two. I salute you for taking it on. Happy exam studying! :)

    ReplyDelete