Sunday, January 12, 2014

Open Prompt Part 2 (2008 1/12/14)


2008. In a literary work, a minor character, often known as a foil, possesses traits that 
emphasize, by contrast or comparison, the distinctive characteristics and qualities of the main character. For example, the ideas or behavior of a minor character might be used to highlight the weaknesses or strengths of the main character. Choose a novel or play in which a minor character serves as a foil for the main character. Then write an essay in which you analyze how the relation between the minor character and the major character illuminates the meaning of the work.

            In Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman Charley is a minor character that is a foil for Willy Loman the main character. Willy is a very proud salesman that is not very successful. His son Happy is similar to him in that sense and his other son Biff is unsuccessful too.  Willy does not see himself or his children clearly, he sees them all as great. Charley contrasts with Willy in every sense; he highlights Willy’s flaws and weakness. Willy is unsuccessful, has children that are similar to himself, and is proud; all of this is highlighted by Charley, and it helps create the meaning of the play that delusions of oneself can lead to the deterioration of one’s self.
            One of the first things that becomes apparent about Willy is that he thinks his job is great though he is barely making any money. He is a salesman and had worked as one for many years. However now he is barely making any money and is later fired by his boss Howard. Charley who is successful on the other hand tries to help him out by offering a job and gives Willy money to give to Linda. Willy instead of taking the job is insulted by it and refuses it, but he does take the money. This highlights the differences between the two and it helps show how out of touch Willy is.

            Willy takes a lot of pride in his children, who have not amounted to much either. Happy is claims to be working as an assistant to a buyer but he is lying about his success. He is also a womanizer. His brother Biff on the other hand was supposed to be a star football player, but he did not take a scholarship offered to him because of an altercation with his father. Biff had left home and was in jail. Charley’s son Bernard though, who was mocked by Willy for not being as popular as Biff when they were in school together, is a very successful lawyer, married, with two kids. This also contrasts with Willy because of how Charley acts about his son, he does not brag or lie about his son unlike Willy. Willy claims that Biff was doing “big things” when he was away. Charley’s behavior draws further attention to Willy’s that shows little grasp of reality.

            The previous two things highlight one of Willy’s biggest flaws: his pride. His pride is what stops him from taking the job that is offered by Charley. Charley offers it to him multiple times and he is insulted by it every single time. This job is the solution to all of his finical problems. Charley tries to offer it to him as no big deal and “just for the hell of it”. He could make it seem like a big favor to Willy, but he does not do that. As opposed to Willy Charley’s pride does not interfere with his life, it is practically nonresistant. Pride contributes to Willy’s eventual downfall and the overall meaning of the play.


            Charley is a foil for Willy in every sense, he and his son are both successful, and he does not have pride that contributes to his unrealistic views of his life. Willy’s unrealistic views contribute to his eventual downfall. His delusion of his own personal success and of his children hurt him and his family. Charley is successful and so is his son. Willy’s pride makes it impossible for him to take the job offered by Charley. Charley does not let pride interfere with anything in his life, he helps Willy without any inhibitions. Charley highlights the many things that contributed to Willy’s downfall. 

3 comments:

  1. Susheela,
    I thought you had a really solid first essay. You identified a great example, Willy and Charley, and came up with some great explanations. I thought you had some great evidence throughout your essay. Besides a few fixable grammatical errors I thought your essay overall was great. One thing I would focus on if I were you is describing how the foil adds to the meaning of the play. This would really drive this essay to that perfect 9. One thing you could include is the fact that Willy kills himself, and Charley, obviously, does not. Discuss how Charley becomes successful, and Willy (debatabley) does not. If you add in those minor elements I think this essay will be well on it's way to a 9. Great work!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Susheela,
    For a first attempt at an essay, this was really, really good. You started off strong with your intro paragraph and your thesis did a good job foreshadowing what you were going to talk about. All of your points are very good and very strong, but there was one thing I would caution you on. In your paragraph about Willy’s pride, you talk about the contrast between Willy and Charley’s pride, a fair point, but I think that the contrast is not between their pride, but how it affects them. Both are equally proud, which is evident by Charley being so offended by Willy constantly refusing the job offer, he believes that Willy thinks he is better than him, which hurts his pride. The really contrast is how they let their pride affect them, which you touched on a little. The one really complaint I have is that there were some flow issues throughout the essay, many of which were due to (a lack of) punctuation. Despite my few nitpicky things, this was a great essay.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Susheela,
    Excellent job bringing in so much textual evidence to this essay. All of your claims were well supported, and you pulled a lot of valid ideas to contrast Charley and Willy. Beyond fixing simple grammar mistakes, however, I would advise going over the structure of the essay. I can see how you broke up your three main ideas—Willy's delusional view of his life versus Charley's well-adjusted take on his, the difference in parenting styles between the two, and then the issue of pride—but some of the concepts still blend together a bit. (See the ending statements in body paragraphs one and two) I would also advise not going into too much detail over the differences between Biff and Howard, simply because they too serve as foils to one another and discussing them at length may prove to be confusing to the reader. Overall though this was a well done essay, great job!

    ReplyDelete