We have spent all of our time focusing
on Hamlet since the last response to course material post post. We read
the play in class together, then watched parts of multiple versions of the
movie, and read poems/articles on it. I missed the first day we started to read
the play in class and that definitely made it all bit confusing. After we first
read the play I had my own version of what the play was in my mind; watching
different versions of Hamlet did change it.
It was interesting watching each
version, they highlighted different things in the play. I really liked the
setting for the Branaugh and Tennet versions. I thought that they both showed
how there was always spying in Elsinore and the idea that there is something
wrong there. Then I liked the casting in the Jacobi version compared to the
other ones, especially for Laertes. I liked the casting in the Hawke version
too, but Hawke’s Hamlet seemed to be monotone. He lacked the complexity that I
personally think is vital to Hamlet. His Hamlet just seemed really
depressed and no other emotion was really apparent in the movie. I thought the
movie had an interesting take on Laertes and Ophelia relationship that the
others didn’t. The play in general reminds me of Death of a Salesman
because of how you discover something new every time you read it or watch it
again.
I really enjoyed reading the articles
on Hamlet, especially the one about the Tiv and their interpretation on the
play Hamlet. It showed how subjective interpretations are and as a result the
“true” meaning is too. The forum posts created a debate over whether there was
a “correct” interpretation. I don’t think there is because everything is
subjective and that includes whatever we personally think is the right version.
This applies to other things too, from movies to music. Then the other two
pieces on the forums were Rimbaud’s poem and the story about prisoners acting
out Shakespeare. Rimbaud’s poem brought to mind who is really to blame for
Ophelia’s death? Is there ever really anyone to to blame with suicide anyway?
What about another Shakespeare play then, can anyone be blamed for Romeo and
Juliet's death? The prisoners also showed Hamlet in a new light because they
could connect with him in a way that we can’t.
We also had in class discussions over
the play and the different versions of Hamlet that we watched. Someone
made the analogy that if Hamlet was in a band he would be the lead singer,
Horatio would be the base player, Polonius would be the stage manager,
the Queen and Ophelia would be groupies, and so on. I thought that this was
funny, but it also did help with understanding the characters. As discussions
continued we started to go more in depth, especially after our close reading.
Another thing that came up was the Biblical references and parallels in play.
Hamlet is typically considered the good guy, but it is hard to deny that there
are parallels with him and Satan. Satan also tried to usurp God and that is
what lead to him to being punished. He also started off as the good guy and it
is apparent in the beginning of the play that he is good, but that changes as
the play goes on. This comparison reminded me of Paradise Lost by
Milton because of comparison with Satan and I learned the more about Satan
after reading it last year in British Literature.
We also annotated Tragic Balance in Hamlet. I’m ended up being absent the day we
discussed it in class, but I heard that it was a good discussion and I know
that some of the classes really didn’t like it. My main issue was that the article
was confusing because of all the ideas and it was difficult to tell which
quotes were supporting the author or an older idea. It was still an interesting
article though.
Susheela,
ReplyDeleteThis was a really good post and you covered pretty much everything we had done in class since the last post. I think the only thing you didn’t mention was the “Tragic Balance in Hamlet” article and I would love to know what you thought about that article. It’s interesting that you said watching the different versions of Hamlet changed you mind on the version of the play in your head because for me the different versions only reinforced what I saw and so led to my liking the movies that better fit my own ideas. Considering it is Hamlet, I think you did a good job connecting it to outside elements, especially your bit about Paradise Lost and comparing Hamlet to Satan. I hadn’t thought about that before, at least not in those terms, but now that you have said it and explained it some, I can see how they connect and how comparisons can be found between the two. Your question about blame and suicide is interesting, and without starting a full blown debate, I think sometimes people can be blamed for suicide (i.e. when a kid is bullied so much they take their own life). So to simply answer your question without an argument, I think in some cases, blame can be placed on someone. Great post Susheela!
Dear Susheela,
ReplyDeleteWow great job discussing the movies! You remember so many details that I can easily recall what you're talking about. As for your question of who (if anyone at all) can be held responsible for a suicide, I would say it's the person who dies. Because they're the ones who aren't strong enough to grit their teeth and push forward through life, even if it sucks. Personally, I wish that Ophelia had been portrayed as stronger. he is such a weak character, submitting to her father, to societal expectations, and then going crazy and killing herself. It makes her look way too frail and pathetic. I blame her. Nice reference to the Hamlet rock band theory we made, I had nearly forgotten about that.
Susheela,
ReplyDeleteYour comparison of Hamlet as a devil figure to Paradise Lost is something I've been considering a bit myself lately. At first I wasn't sure if I was in complete agreement with this as it was brought up in class, but as we've discussed it further and begun considering that Hamlet's actions are akin to usurping the powers of God I realize that he is most certainly comparable to Lucifer. There are clearly distinct parallels between the works of Hamlet and Paradise Lost that would be fun to explore.
I'd like to hear more on your ideas regarding the Hamlet in Prison segment we listened to. I found it intriguing to hear how people with completely different backgrounds to ours--that is, AP students versus criminals--interpreted and related to the different situations involved in the play.
The fact that I am in your class and don't remember the Hamlet band discussion concerns me, mostly because that sounds like a great conversation. Perhaps I'll bring it up again on Monday and we can rehash it.
I think you covered everything necessary, except perhaps for the Shakespeare Uncovered documentary we watched in class, but no matter. Great work on this post!