2008 “The prompt for question 3, the “open” question, began by noting that in literary works, a minor character, often known as a foil, possesses traits that emphasize, by contrast or comparison, the distinctive characteristics and qualities of the main character. The prompt added that the ideas or behavior of the minor character might be used to highlight the weaknesses or strengths of the main character. Students were then asked to choose a novel or play in which a minor character serves as a foil to a main character and to write an essay analyzing how the relation between the minor character and the major character illuminates the meaning of the work as a whole”.
Essay 3A:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Joy Luck Club. One of the flaws of the essay is that the second and third paragraphs are mostly filled with plot summary. There is very little, if any, analysis in the paragraphs. This is clear when you first start to read the essay. The student received an 8, if they had more analysis with the summary and/or less summarization in the essay as a whole they probably could have gotten a 9. The paragraph has a very good ending; it had a quote from the book and it helped wrap up the paragraph. The student had an adequate conclusion; it started with restating the thesis. Then ended with a strong and clear sentence: “Hung Taitai helped to highlight and emphasize all of Lindos good qualities”. This sentence specifically answered the prompt, though it was less clear throughout the essay. It is a bit surprising that the essay received an 8 because it seemed to summarize too much, not focus on answering the prompt, and it didn’t have enough analysis. The essay did have a lot of evidence and a good introduction.
Essay 3B:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Color Purple. This was a fairly good essay overall. One problem that was noticeable early on was that the prompt was not answered early in the essay. Ideally the prompt would be answered in the first paragraph. It is only clear in the conclusion that the Celle’s father “serv(es) as her foil, he represents every characteristic that Celle learns not to be”. This is the only time that the prompt was directly answered and that was in the conclusion, which is late. The other issue with the essay is that there is more evidence for Shug to be Celle’s foil instead of her father in the essay. The student says that Celle was not independent and Shug is the opposite of that. This is discussed in the essay and it is unclear who the foil is till the end of the essay is. It received a 6 and I can understand why. The essay was fairly well written, but it was a bit confusing.
Essay 3C:
The student chose to write an essay about the book The Kite Runner. The student should try to vary his/her sentence structure more in the future. Majority of the sentences in the essay are fairly simple, “he emphasizes the good qualities in Hassan”. This would be fine if the short simple sentences were only used once in a while, especially to create emphasis. The problem is that they are common in the essay and as a result there is now flow. Also while some of the previous essays summarized too much, this one did not give a summary or background information on the plot much at all. This makes it difficult for someone who has not read the book to understand the essay. The student should also try to use more evidence and explain it. He/she did answer the prompt but not very well. The essay got a 4 and I agree with the score. The essay was underdeveloped, but it answered the prompt and has room for potential.
Susheela,
ReplyDeleteYou did a good job analyzing these essays. Having read them for a previous Open Prompt blog, I really understood what you were saying in your analyses, even if you saw them in a better light and didn’t rip into them as I did. Like you, I questioned how essay 3A received an 8, what with its extensive plot summary and seemingly lack of focus when answering the prompt, but I hadn’t noticed before that the introduction and evidentiary support were good (thanks for bringing that to my attention). It’s interesting to see you agreeing with the readers’ scores on 3B and 3C and your reasoning, as I had disagreed with the scores. Maybe you’re approaching these essays like the AP readers do in seeing how the essay got what it did. I would be interested to know if you would have scored any of these essays differently even though you agree with most of the scores (especially on 3A, I’m curious as to what you would have given that essay instead). Overall you did a great job analyzing each of these essays and understanding how the essay brought in the prompt; great job Susheela.
Dear Susheela,
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like the first essay was just not pointed enough. It is hard to draw the line between how much background is necessary and how much is just off-topic summarizing. Honestly an easy solution to the problems in both the first and second essay is to draft a quick outline. That way you know right where to put the thesis and the central focus of each paragraph. As for the third, I trust that your analysis is good and they probably just needed to offer more background and more detail.
Susheela,
ReplyDeleteYou make a valid point in your critique of the first essay; it did come off as more of a summary of the novel rather than an analysis of the foils present. Why it received such a high score is beyond me. 'Tis all part of the mystery surrounding the AP College Board graders, I guess.
I thought the second essay was unclear as to who served as Celle's foil as well. I assume that this was the main reason it was given a lower score; beyond that flaw the writer was sure to add a fair amount of evidence from the novel to assert its positions, so I’m guessing the lack of clarity is what hurt the writer in the end.
Good work including evidence from the essays themselves; I feel that's important for a good critique on these posts. Overall your responses were very solid and critiqued the student’s work well, great work!